| Lineup | St. John Fisher | PG - Ryan George (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SG - Dustin Stroup (fresh) 6 pts. SF - Steven Hurt (fresh) 3 pts. 3 reb. PF - Herman Casella (fresh) 7 pts. 3 reb. C - Carl Grayer (fresh) 4 reb. | |
| Lineup | Muhlenberg | PG - Aaron Zylstra (fresh) 6 pts. 1 ast. SG - Matthew Spoon (fresh) 2 pts. 2 ast. SF - Roman Lopez (fresh) PF - Thomas Wilson (fresh) 5 pts. 7 reb. C - Ron Cook (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | St. John Fisher | Steven Hurt inbounds the ball | 39-31 |
| Game Plan | St. John Fisher | St. John Fisher is playing a motion offense and a 2-3 zone (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Muhlenberg | Muhlenberg is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (-1) | |
| 19:43 | St. John Fisher | Dustin Stroup is whistled for a carry | 39-31 |
| 19:26 | Muhlenberg | Ryan George is called for the reach on Matthew Spoon - foul #3 on Ryan George, team foul #1 | 39-31 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson (PG) Ryan George | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | | |
| 19:09 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson misses long on a jumper in the lane | 39-31 |
| 19:08 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson tips it home | 39-33 |
| 19:03 | St. John Fisher | Thomas Wilson swats the layup by Herman Casella | 39-33 |
| 19:02 | St. John Fisher | Steven Hurt grabs the offensive board | 39-33 |
| 18:44 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer hits a jumper in the lane | 41-33 |
| 18:27 | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon is hacked by Dustin Stroup - foul #3 on Dustin Stroup, team foul #2 | 41-33 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Tracy Mikel (SG) Dustin Stroup | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | | |
| 18:06 | Muhlenberg | Ron Cook's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 41-33 |
| 17:46 | St. John Fisher | Steven Hurt misses long on a jumper from the baseline but he's fouled by Roman Lopez - foul #1 on Roman Lopez, team foul #1 | 41-33 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Dennis Williams (PF) Thomas Wilson | |
| 17:46 | St. John Fisher | Steven Hurt makes the 1st free throw | 42-33 |
| 17:46 | St. John Fisher | Steven Hurt makes the 2nd free throw | 43-33 |
| 17:26 | Muhlenberg | Roman Lopez drills a 3 pointer from the right corner | 43-36 |
| 17:05 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer clanks a turnaround from close range | 43-36 |
| 17:03 | Muhlenberg | Roman Lopez grabs the defensive rebound | 43-36 |
| 16:51 | Muhlenberg | Dennis Williams's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 43-36 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Chad Grunewald (PG), Kevin Cecere (SF), Michael Hall (PF), Joseph Mills (C) Earl Vinson, Steven Hurt, Herman Casella, Carl Grayer | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | William Venuti (PG), Richard Evans (SG), Benjamin Daniels (PF), John Morphis (C) Aaron Zylstra, Matthew Spoon, Roman Lopez, Ron Cook | |
| 16:36 | St. John Fisher | Michael Hall misses the runner from close range | 43-36 |
| 16:34 | St. John Fisher | Kevin Cecere pulls down the offensive rebound | 43-36 |
| 16:19 | St. John Fisher | Michael Hall misses the lay-in | 43-36 |
| 16:18 | St. John Fisher | Kevin Cecere can't tip it in | 43-36 |
| 16:16 | Muhlenberg | William Venuti pulls down the rebound | 43-36 |
| 15:54 | Muhlenberg | Chad Grunewald steps in front of the William Venuti pass | 43-36 |
| 15:49 | St. John Fisher | Chad Grunewald misses the easy layup | 43-36 |
| 15:47 | Muhlenberg | Benjamin Daniels pulls down the rebound | 43-36 |
| Lineup | St. John Fisher | PG - Chad Grunewald (fresh) 4 pts. SG - Tracy Mikel (fresh) 6 pts. SF - Kevin Cecere (fresh) 3 reb. PF - Michael Hall (fresh) 2 pts. 4 reb. C - Joseph Mills (fresh) 4 pts. | |
| Lineup | Muhlenberg | PG - William Venuti (fresh) 4 pts. 1 ast. SG - Richard Evans (fresh) 1 ast. SF - Dennis Williams (fresh) 4 pts. 3 reb. PF - Benjamin Daniels (fresh) 4 pts. C - John Morphis (fresh) 2 reb. | |
| 15:28 | Muhlenberg | Richard Evans is fouled on the floor by Tracy Mikel - foul #1 on Tracy Mikel, team foul #3 | 43-36 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Ryan George (PG), Dustin Stroup (SG), Steven Hurt (SF), Herman Casella (PF), Carl Grayer (C) Chad Grunewald, Tracy Mikel, Kevin Cecere, Michael Hall, Joseph Mills | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon (SG), Roman Lopez (SF), Thomas Wilson (PF), Ron Cook (C) Richard Evans, Dennis Williams, Benjamin Daniels, John Morphis | |
| 15:14 | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon drills a 3 from straight away | 43-39 |
| 14:51 | St. John Fisher | Herman Casella hits a runner near the basket | 45-39 |
| 14:40 | Muhlenberg | Ryan George is called for the reach on Thomas Wilson - foul #4 on Ryan George, team foul #4 | 45-39 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson (PG) Ryan George | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra (PG) William Venuti | |
| 14:28 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson loses the dribble to Herman Casella | 45-39 |
| 14:11 | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson makes the jumpshot from the right side on a nice dish by Dustin Stroup | 47-39 |
| 14:00 | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra makes the 3pt shot from the right corner | 47-42 |
| 13:42 | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson misses long on a jumper from the left side | 47-42 |
| 13:40 | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon pulls down the rebound | 47-42 |
| 13:18 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson clanks a floater from the right wing | 47-42 |
| 13:16 | St. John Fisher | The rebound goes to Herman Casella | 47-42 |
| 13:04 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer travels with the ball | 47-42 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Kevin Cecere (SF), Michael Hall (PF), Joseph Mills (C) Steven Hurt, Herman Casella, Carl Grayer | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Dennis Williams (SF), Benjamin Daniels (PF), John Morphis (C) Roman Lopez, Thomas Wilson, Ron Cook | |
| 12:56 | Muhlenberg | Dennis Williams knocks in the fadeaway jumper from the free throw line set up by Matthew Spoon | 47-44 |
| 12:35 | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson connects on the shot from the free throw line | 49-44 |
| 12:22 | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra misses short on a 3pt shot from the left corner | 49-44 |
| 12:20 | St. John Fisher | Dustin Stroup pulls down the rebound | 49-44 |
| 11:51 | St. John Fisher | Dustin Stroup comes up short on the 3 from the right wing | 49-44 |
| 11:49 | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson pulls down the offensive rebound | 49-44 |
| 11:27 | St. John Fisher | Kevin Cecere misses long on a turnaround in the paint | 49-44 |
| 11:26 | Muhlenberg | Dennis Williams pulls down the rebound | 49-44 |
| Lineup | St. John Fisher | PG - Earl Vinson (fairly fresh) 6 pts. 2 ast. SG - Dustin Stroup (fairly fresh) 6 pts. 1 ast. 3 pf. SF - Kevin Cecere (fresh) 3 reb. PF - Michael Hall (fresh) 2 pts. 4 reb. C - Joseph Mills (fresh) 4 pts. | |
| Lineup | Muhlenberg | PG - Aaron Zylstra (fairly fresh) 9 pts. 1 ast. SG - Matthew Spoon (fairly fresh) 5 pts. 3 ast. SF - Dennis Williams (fresh) 6 pts. 4 reb. PF - Benjamin Daniels (fresh) 4 pts. C - John Morphis (fresh) 2 reb. | |
| 11:21 | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon comes up short on the 3pt attempt from the right wing | 49-44 |
| 11:19 | St. John Fisher | Kevin Cecere grabs the board | 49-44 |
| 10:55 | St. John Fisher | Michael Hall can't finish the layup | 49-44 |
| 10:53 | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon gets the rebound | 49-44 |
| 10:31 | Muhlenberg | Benjamin Daniels comes up short on the turnaround near the basket | 49-44 |
| 10:30 | St. John Fisher | Michael Hall pulls down the rebound | 49-44 |
| 10:14 | St. John Fisher | Dustin Stroup makes the 3pt attempt from the left corner | 52-44 |
| 10:08 | Muhlenberg | John Morphis hits a 3 pointer from the left wing on a nice dish by Benjamin Daniels | 52-47 |
| 09:46 | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson throws a bad pass out of bounds | 52-47 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Chad Grunewald (PG), Tracy Mikel (SG), Steven Hurt (SF), Herman Casella (PF), Carl Grayer (C) Earl Vinson, Dustin Stroup, Kevin Cecere, Michael Hall, Joseph Mills | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | William Venuti (PG), Richard Evans (SG), Roman Lopez (SF), Thomas Wilson (PF), Ron Cook (C) Aaron Zylstra, Matthew Spoon, Dennis Williams, Benjamin Daniels, John Morphis | |
| 09:31 | Muhlenberg | Roman Lopez misses long on a 3 pointer from the left wing | 52-47 |
| 09:30 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer grabs the defensive rebound | 52-47 |
| 09:08 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer misses the lay-in but the foul's on Richard Evans - foul #2 on Richard Evans, team foul #2 | 52-47 |
| 09:08 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer makes the 1st free throw | 53-47 |
| 09:08 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer misses the 2nd free throw | 53-47 |
| 09:08 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson snags the defensive board | 53-47 |
| 08:46 | Muhlenberg | The jump hook by Thomas Wilson is blocked by Carl Grayer | 53-47 |
| 08:45 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer grabs the defensive rebound | 53-47 |
| 08:23 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer scores on a floater from the left block | 55-47 |
| 08:10 | Muhlenberg | Roman Lopez misses badly on a 3 from the right corner | 55-47 |
| 08:08 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer gets the rebound | 55-47 |
| 07:45 | St. John Fisher | Chad Grunewald's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 55-47 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Ryan George (PG) Chad Grunewald | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon (SG) Richard Evans | |
| 07:38 | Muhlenberg | Roman Lopez buries a 3pt attempt from the left corner on a great pass from Matthew Spoon | 55-50 |
| 07:24 | St. John Fisher | Tracy Mikel misses the jumpshot from the right side | 55-50 |
| 07:22 | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon grabs the defensive rebound | 55-50 |
| Lineup | St. John Fisher | PG - Ryan George (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. 4 pf. SG - Tracy Mikel (fresh) 6 pts. SF - Steven Hurt (fresh) 5 pts. 4 reb. PF - Herman Casella (fresh) 9 pts. 4 reb. C - Carl Grayer (fresh) 5 pts. 7 reb. 2 blk. | |
| Lineup | Muhlenberg | PG - William Venuti (fresh) 4 pts. 1 ast. SG - Matthew Spoon (fresh) 5 pts. 4 ast. SF - Roman Lopez (fresh) 6 pts. PF - Thomas Wilson (fairly fresh) 7 pts. 9 reb. C - Ron Cook (fresh) | |
| 07:07 | Muhlenberg | Roman Lopez's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 55-50 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson (SG), Michael Hall (C) Tracy Mikel, Carl Grayer | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Dennis Williams (SF), Benjamin Daniels (PF) Roman Lopez, Thomas Wilson | |
| 06:56 | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson knocks in the 3pt jumper from the right corner | 58-50 |
| 06:36 | Muhlenberg | Ron Cook is whistled for traveling | 58-50 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Dustin Stroup (SG), Kevin Cecere (SF), Joseph Mills (C) Earl Vinson, Steven Hurt, Herman Casella | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Richard Evans (PG), John Morphis (C) William Venuti, Ron Cook | |
| 06:23 | St. John Fisher | Ryan George can't connect on a 3 from the right wing | 58-50 |
| 06:22 | Muhlenberg | John Morphis gets the rebound | 58-50 |
| 06:01 | Muhlenberg | Benjamin Daniels misses long on a pull-up jumper from just outside the lane | 58-50 |
| 06:00 | Muhlenberg | Richard Evans tips it in | 58-52 |
| 05:40 | St. John Fisher | Joseph Mills hits the front of the rim on the floater in the paint | 58-52 |
| 05:39 | Muhlenberg | The rebound goes to Richard Evans | 58-52 |
| 05:19 | Muhlenberg | John Morphis connects on the floater from the left wing set up by Dennis Williams | 58-54 |
| 05:02 | St. John Fisher | Benjamin Daniels takes the ball from Kevin Cecere | 58-54 |
| 05:02 | Muhlenberg | Muhlenberg calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 58-54 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Steven Hurt (SF), Herman Casella (PF), Carl Grayer (C) Kevin Cecere, Michael Hall, Joseph Mills | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra (PG), Roman Lopez (SF), Thomas Wilson (PF), Ron Cook (C) Richard Evans, Dennis Williams, Benjamin Daniels, John Morphis | |
| 04:52 | Muhlenberg | Dustin Stroup is called for the reach on Roman Lopez - foul #4 on Dustin Stroup, team foul #5 | 58-54 |
| 04:47 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson is denied on a layup by Carl Grayer | 58-54 |
| 04:45 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer pulls down the rebound | 58-54 |
| 04:34 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer connects on the shot in the paint set up by Steven Hurt | 60-54 |
| 04:21 | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra hits the front of the rim on the floater from just outside the lane | 60-54 |
| 04:20 | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra grabs the offensive rebound | 60-54 |
| 04:00 | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra misses the 3 pointer from the left corner | 60-54 |
| 03:58 | St. John Fisher | Steven Hurt pulls down the rebound | 60-54 |
| 03:42 | St. John Fisher | Ryan George misses long on a floater from the right side | 60-54 |
| 03:41 | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon gets the rebound | 60-54 |
| 03:23 | Muhlenberg | A charge is called on Roman Lopez - foul #2 on Roman Lopez, team foul #3 | 60-54 |
| Lineup | St. John Fisher | PG - Ryan George (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. 4 pf. SG - Dustin Stroup (fresh) 9 pts. 1 ast. 4 pf. SF - Steven Hurt (fresh) 5 pts. 5 reb. PF - Herman Casella (fresh) 9 pts. 4 reb. C - Carl Grayer (fresh) 7 pts. 8 reb. 3 blk. | |
| Lineup | Muhlenberg | PG - Aaron Zylstra (fresh) 9 pts. 1 ast. SG - Matthew Spoon (fresh) 5 pts. 4 ast. SF - Roman Lopez (fresh) 6 pts. PF - Thomas Wilson (fresh) 7 pts. 9 reb. C - Ron Cook (fresh) | |
| 03:04 | St. John Fisher | Steven Hurt misses short on a 3 pointer from straight away | 60-54 |
| 03:02 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson snags the defensive board | 60-54 |
| 02:56 | Muhlenberg | Ron Cook misses the 3pt shot from straight away | 60-54 |
| 02:55 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer pulls down the rebound | 60-54 |
| 02:44 | St. John Fisher | Ryan George comes up short on the 3pt shot from the left wing | 60-54 |
| 02:42 | St. John Fisher | Steven Hurt pulls down the offensive rebound | 60-54 |
| 02:33 | St. John Fisher | Ryan George misses long on a 3pt shot from the left wing | 60-54 |
| 02:31 | Muhlenberg | Ron Cook gets the rebound | 60-54 |
| 02:29 | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra throws a bad pass out of bounds in the backcourt | 60-54 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson (PG), Tracy Mikel (SG) Ryan George, Dustin Stroup | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | William Venuti (PG), Dennis Williams (SG), Benjamin Daniels (PF) Aaron Zylstra, Matthew Spoon, Thomas Wilson | |
| 02:16 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer comes up short on the runner from the left block but he's fouled by Ron Cook - foul #3 on Ron Cook, team foul #4 | 60-54 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Kevin Cecere (SF) Steven Hurt | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Richard Evans (SG), John Morphis (C) Roman Lopez, Ron Cook | |
| 02:16 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer makes the 1st free throw | 61-54 |
| 02:16 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer makes the 2nd free throw | 62-54 |
| Game Plan | St. John Fisher | St. John Fisher is playing a motion offense and a 2-3 zone (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Muhlenberg | Muhlenberg is playing a triangle offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 02:12 | Muhlenberg | Muhlenberg calls a full timeout (2 :30 2 full remaining) | 62-54 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Ryan George (PG), Dustin Stroup (SG), Steven Hurt (SF) Earl Vinson, Tracy Mikel, Kevin Cecere | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra (PG), Matthew Spoon (SG), Roman Lopez (SF), Thomas Wilson (PF), Ron Cook (C) William Venuti, Richard Evans, Dennis Williams, Benjamin Daniels, John Morphis | |
| 02:03 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson misses short on a runner near the basket but he's hacked by Herman Casella - foul #1 on Herman Casella, team foul #6 | 62-54 |
| 02:03 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson misses the 1st free throw | 62-54 |
| 02:03 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson misses the 2nd free throw | 62-54 |
| 02:03 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer gets the rebound | 62-54 |
| Game Plan | St. John Fisher | St. John Fisher is playing a motion offense (slowdown) and a 2-3 zone (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Muhlenberg | Muhlenberg is playing a triangle offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 01:40 | St. John Fisher | Herman Casella lays it in | 64-54 |
| 01:19 | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra buries a floater from the left wing | 64-56 |
| 00:50 | St. John Fisher | Ryan George hits the front of the rim on the fadeaway from the left wing but he's fouled by Ron Cook - foul #4 on Ron Cook, team foul #5 | 64-56 |
| 00:50 | St. John Fisher | Ryan George misses the 1st free throw | 64-56 |
| 00:50 | St. John Fisher | Ryan George makes the 2nd free throw | 65-56 |
| Game Plan | St. John Fisher | St. John Fisher is playing a motion offense (slowdown) and a 2-3 zone (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Muhlenberg | Muhlenberg is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 00:42 | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon is fouled on the floor by Dustin Stroup - foul #5 on Dustin Stroup, team foul #7 | 65-56 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Earl Vinson (SG) Dustin Stroup | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | | |
| 00:42 | Muhlenberg | Matthew Spoon misses the 1st free throw | 65-56 |
| 00:42 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer grabs the defensive rebound | 65-56 |
| Game Plan | St. John Fisher | St. John Fisher is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a 2-3 zone (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Muhlenberg | Muhlenberg is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and intentionally fouling (-1) | |
| 00:40 | St. John Fisher | Carl Grayer is fouled in the backcourt by Matthew Spoon - foul #3 on Matthew Spoon, team foul #6 | 65-56 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Tracy Mikel (SF) Steven Hurt | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | | |
| 00:39 | St. John Fisher | Matthew Spoon is called for the reach on Ryan George - foul #4 on Matthew Spoon, team foul #7 | 65-56 |
| 00:39 | St. John Fisher | Ryan George makes the 1st free throw | 66-56 |
| 00:39 | St. John Fisher | Ryan George makes the 2nd free throw | 67-56 |
| 00:32 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson hits the front of the rim on the pull-up jumper from the left wing | 67-56 |
| 00:30 | Muhlenberg | The offensive rebound goes to Aaron Zylstra | 67-56 |
| 00:27 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Wilson comes up short on the 3pt shot from the left corner | 67-56 |
| 00:25 | Muhlenberg | Roman Lopez grabs the offensive board | 67-56 |
| 00:22 | Muhlenberg | Aaron Zylstra is whistled for traveling | 67-56 |
| Subs | St. John Fisher | Chad Grunewald (PG), Michael Hall (PF), Kevin Cecere (C) Ryan George, Herman Casella, Carl Grayer | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | William Venuti (PG), Richard Evans (SG), Dennis Williams (SF), Benjamin Daniels (PF), John Morphis (C) Aaron Zylstra, Matthew Spoon, Roman Lopez, Thomas Wilson, Ron Cook | |
| Game Plan | St. John Fisher | St. John Fisher is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a 2-3 zone (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Muhlenberg | Muhlenberg is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 00:00 | St. John Fisher | Chad Grunewald runs out the clock | 67-56 |