| Lineup | Seton Hall | PG - Andrew Pelkey (fresh) SG - Travis Leyva (fresh) SF - Roger Valera (fresh) PF - Erik Sullivan (fresh) C - Oscar Dicks (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Thomas Barnes (fresh) SG - Tommy Klopfenstein (fresh) SF - Jim Kloss (fresh) PF - Keith Morning (fresh) C - Ronnie Bradley (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | Colgate | Keith Morning wins the tip | 0-0 |
| Game Plan | Seton Hall | Seton Hall is playing a fastbreak offense and a man to man (0) | |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a motion offense and a man to man (0) | |
| 19:32 | Colgate | Jim Kloss can't connect on a fadeaway jumper from just outside the lane | 0-0 |
| 19:30 | Colgate | Keith Morning tips it back up and in | 0-2 |
| 19:24 | Seton Hall | Andrew Pelkey misses badly on a 3 pointer from the right wing | 0-2 |
| 19:22 | Seton Hall | The offensive rebound goes to Oscar Dicks | 0-2 |
| 19:07 | Seton Hall | Roger Valera misses the shot from the right wing | 0-2 |
| 19:06 | Colgate | Ronnie Bradley gets the rebound | 0-2 |
| 18:45 | Colgate | Thomas Barnes can't connect on a 3pt shot from the left corner | 0-2 |
| 18:44 | Seton Hall | Oscar Dicks grabs the defensive rebound | 0-2 |
| 18:37 | Seton Hall | Erik Sullivan scores on a shot from the baseline on a great pass from Roger Valera | 2-2 |
| 18:19 | Colgate | Thomas Barnes can't finish the layup | 2-2 |
| 18:17 | Seton Hall | Roger Valera pulls down the rebound | 2-2 |
| 18:00 | Seton Hall | Travis Leyva lays it up and in | 4-2 |
| 17:40 | Colgate | Travis Leyva is called for the reach on Keith Morning - foul #1 on Travis Leyva, team foul #1 | 4-2 |
| 17:25 | Colgate | Oscar Dicks steps in front of the Jim Kloss pass | 4-2 |
| 17:20 | Seton Hall | Roger Valera's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 4-2 |
| 17:15 | Colgate | Andrew Pelkey steals the ball from Thomas Barnes in the backcourt | 4-2 |
| 17:03 | Seton Hall | Ronnie Bradley is called for the reach on Erik Sullivan - foul #1 on Ronnie Bradley, team foul #1 | 4-2 |
| 16:48 | Seton Hall | Roger Valera connects on the jumper from the right wing and the foul's on Ronnie Bradley - foul #2 on Ronnie Bradley, team foul #2 | 6-2 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | | |
| Subs | Colgate | Paul Nagy (SF), Enlai Ximines (C) Jim Kloss, Ronnie Bradley | |
| 16:48 | Seton Hall | Roger Valera makes the free throw | 7-2 |
| 16:35 | Colgate | Paul Nagy misses short on a runner from the right block but he's hacked by Travis Leyva - foul #2 on Travis Leyva, team foul #2 | 7-2 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Edward Baker (SG) Travis Leyva | |
| Subs | Colgate | Clarence Glass (SF) Keith Morning | |
| 16:35 | Colgate | Paul Nagy misses the 1st free throw | 7-2 |
| 16:35 | Colgate | Paul Nagy makes the 2nd free throw | 7-3 |
| 16:21 | Seton Hall | Enlai Ximines steals it from Edward Baker | 7-3 |
| 16:05 | Colgate | Paul Nagy is fouled on the floor by Oscar Dicks - foul #1 on Oscar Dicks, team foul #3 | 7-3 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Zachariah Randle (SF), Michael Knupp (PF), Lloyd Peeler (C) Roger Valera, Erik Sullivan, Oscar Dicks | |
| Subs | Colgate | Jim Eliason (PG), Jerry Quintanar (SG) Thomas Barnes, Tommy Klopfenstein | |
| 15:52 | Colgate | Jerry Quintanar is fouled on the floor by Edward Baker - foul #1 on Edward Baker, team foul #4 | 7-3 |
| Lineup | Seton Hall | PG - Andrew Pelkey (fairly fresh) SG - Edward Baker (fresh) SF - Zachariah Randle (fresh) PF - Michael Knupp (fresh) C - Lloyd Peeler (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Jim Eliason (fresh) SG - Jerry Quintanar (fresh) SF - Clarence Glass (fresh) PF - Paul Nagy (fresh) 1 pts. C - Enlai Ximines (fresh) | |
| 15:34 | Colgate | Zachariah Randle takes the ball from Enlai Ximines | 7-3 |
| 15:30 | Seton Hall | Edward Baker blows the layup | 7-3 |
| 15:28 | Colgate | The rebound goes to Jim Eliason | 7-3 |
| 15:24 | Colgate | Jerry Quintanar clanks a 3pt shot from the right wing | 7-3 |
| 15:22 | Seton Hall | Lloyd Peeler grabs the board | 7-3 |
| 15:12 | Seton Hall | Lloyd Peeler comes up short on the 3pt attempt from the right corner | 7-3 |
| 15:11 | Colgate | The rebound goes to Paul Nagy | 7-3 |
| 15:06 | Colgate | Jim Eliason makes the 3 from the left corner set up by Paul Nagy | 7-6 |
| 14:43 | Seton Hall | Zachariah Randle clanks a fadeaway from the right block but he's fouled by Clarence Glass - foul #1 on Clarence Glass, team foul #3 | 7-6 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Roger Valera (SF), Oscar Dicks (C) Andrew Pelkey, Lloyd Peeler | |
| Subs | Colgate | Thomas Barnes (PG), Tommy Klopfenstein (SG), Jim Kloss (SF), Keith Morning (PF) Jim Eliason, Jerry Quintanar, Clarence Glass, Enlai Ximines | |
| 14:43 | Seton Hall | Zachariah Randle misses the 1st free throw | 7-6 |
| 14:43 | Seton Hall | Zachariah Randle makes the 2nd free throw | 8-6 |
| 14:32 | Colgate | Paul Nagy drills a shot near the basket on a great pass from Thomas Barnes | 8-8 |
| 14:28 | Seton Hall | Oscar Dicks loses the ball out of bounds | 8-8 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Erik Sullivan (PF) Michael Knupp | |
| Subs | Colgate | | |
| 14:14 | Colgate | Paul Nagy is whistled for a carry | 8-8 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Andrew Pelkey (PG) Zachariah Randle | |
| Subs | Colgate | | |
| 13:53 | Seton Hall | Edward Baker is hacked by Jim Kloss - foul #1 on Jim Kloss, team foul #4 | 8-8 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | | |
| Subs | Colgate | Enlai Ximines (C) Paul Nagy | |
| 13:47 | Seton Hall | Edward Baker buries a floater from the right side set up by Andrew Pelkey | 10-8 |
| 13:31 | Colgate | Enlai Ximines misses badly on a 3pt attempt from the left wing | 10-8 |
| 13:30 | Colgate | Jim Kloss gets the offensive rebound | 10-8 |
| 13:12 | Colgate | Tommy Klopfenstein misses long on a 3pt shot from the right corner but he's hacked by Edward Baker - foul #2 on Edward Baker, team foul #5 | 10-8 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Zachariah Randle (SG), Michael Knupp (PF), Lloyd Peeler (C) Edward Baker, Erik Sullivan, Oscar Dicks | |
| Subs | Colgate | | |
| 13:12 | Colgate | Tommy Klopfenstein makes the 1st free throw | 10-9 |
| 13:12 | Colgate | Tommy Klopfenstein makes the 2nd free throw | 10-10 |
| 13:12 | Colgate | Tommy Klopfenstein makes the 3rd free throw | 10-11 |
| 12:54 | Seton Hall | Lloyd Peeler hits a fadeaway from the baseline set up by Roger Valera | 12-11 |
| 12:31 | Colgate | Tommy Klopfenstein misses badly on a fadeaway near the basket | 12-11 |
| 12:29 | Seton Hall | The rebound goes to Zachariah Randle | 12-11 |
| 12:24 | Seton Hall | Enlai Ximines blocks the short jumper by Zachariah Randle | 12-11 |
| 12:22 | Colgate | Keith Morning gets the rebound | 12-11 |
| 12:08 | Colgate | Keith Morning hits the finger roll on a great pass from Tommy Klopfenstein | 12-13 |
| 12:03 | Seton Hall | Zachariah Randle misses the 3 pointer from the right corner | 12-13 |
| 12:01 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp hits the follow up shot | 14-13 |
| 11:37 | Colgate | Thomas Barnes misses short on a floater from just outside the lane | 14-13 |
| 11:35 | Colgate | The offensive rebound goes to Jim Kloss | 14-13 |
| Lineup | Seton Hall | PG - Andrew Pelkey (tiring) 1 ast. SG - Zachariah Randle (fairly fresh) 1 pts. SF - Roger Valera (fairly fresh) 3 pts. PF - Michael Knupp (fresh) 2 pts. C - Lloyd Peeler (fresh) 2 pts. | |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Thomas Barnes (fairly fresh) 1 ast. SG - Tommy Klopfenstein (fairly fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SF - Jim Kloss (fairly fresh) 2 reb. PF - Keith Morning (fairly fresh) 4 pts. 2 reb. C - Enlai Ximines (fairly fresh) | |
| 11:26 | Colgate | Tommy Klopfenstein misses the shot from the baseline | 14-13 |
| 11:24 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp snags the defensive board | 14-13 |
| 11:17 | Seton Hall | Tommy Klopfenstein is called for the reach on Zachariah Randle - foul #1 on Tommy Klopfenstein, team foul #5 | 14-13 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Erik Sullivan (PF), Oscar Dicks (C) Michael Knupp, Lloyd Peeler | |
| Subs | Colgate | Jim Eliason (PG), Jerry Quintanar (SG), Clarence Glass (SF), Paul Nagy (C) Thomas Barnes, Tommy Klopfenstein, Jim Kloss, Enlai Ximines | |
| 11:02 | Seton Hall | Andrew Pelkey clanks a jumpshot from the right side | 14-13 |
| 11:01 | Seton Hall | Zachariah Randle snags the offensive board | 14-13 |
| 10:39 | Seton Hall | Erik Sullivan can't connect on a 3pt shot from the left wing | 14-13 |
| 10:38 | Colgate | Paul Nagy grabs the defensive rebound | 14-13 |
| 10:26 | Colgate | Jim Eliason clanks a 3 pointer from the right wing | 14-13 |
| 10:24 | Colgate | The offensive rebound goes to Jerry Quintanar | 14-13 |
| 10:19 | Colgate | Keith Morning hits a driving attempt from close range set up by Jerry Quintanar | 14-15 |
| 09:53 | Seton Hall | Andrew Pelkey comes up short on the floater from the right side | 14-15 |
| 09:52 | Colgate | Paul Nagy gets the rebound | 14-15 |
| 09:46 | Colgate | Paul Nagy clanks a 3 from straight away | 14-15 |
| 09:44 | Colgate | Keith Morning snags the offensive board | 14-15 |
| 09:34 | Colgate | Jim Eliason is fouled on the floor by Oscar Dicks - foul #2 on Oscar Dicks, team foul #6 | 14-15 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp (C) Oscar Dicks | |
| Subs | Colgate | Thomas Barnes (PG) Jerry Quintanar | |
| 09:22 | Colgate | Thomas Barnes makes the 3pt jumper from the right corner on a great pass from Jim Eliason | 14-18 |
| 09:07 | Seton Hall | Erik Sullivan is whistled for a carry | 14-18 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Lloyd Peeler (C) Erik Sullivan | |
| Subs | Colgate | Tommy Klopfenstein (SG), Jerry Quintanar (SF), Enlai Ximines (C) Jim Eliason, Clarence Glass, Keith Morning | |
| 08:57 | Colgate | Thomas Barnes misses badly on a driving attempt in the paint | 14-18 |
| 08:56 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp pulls down the rebound | 14-18 |
| 08:54 | Seton Hall | Andrew Pelkey is called for a charge in the backcourt - foul #1 on Andrew Pelkey, team foul #7 | 14-18 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | | |
| Subs | Colgate | Jim Kloss (SF) Jerry Quintanar | |
| 08:39 | Colgate | Thomas Barnes clanks a 3pt shot from the left wing | 14-18 |
| 08:37 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp grabs the board | 14-18 |
| 08:31 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp knocks in the jumper from the right block set up by Andrew Pelkey | 16-18 |
| 08:12 | Colgate | Jim Kloss misses long on a jumper from the left wing | 16-18 |
| 08:11 | Seton Hall | Lloyd Peeler grabs the defensive rebound | 16-18 |
| 07:57 | Seton Hall | Zachariah Randle clanks a 3pt shot from the left corner | 16-18 |
| 07:55 | Colgate | The rebound goes to Paul Nagy | 16-18 |
| 07:44 | Colgate | Tommy Klopfenstein scores on a runner near the basket on a great pass from Jim Kloss and the foul's on Lloyd Peeler - foul #1 on Lloyd Peeler, team foul #8 | 16-20 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Erik Sullivan (PF) Lloyd Peeler | |
| Subs | Colgate | Jim Eliason (PG), Keith Morning (PF), Clarence Glass (C) Thomas Barnes, Enlai Ximines, Paul Nagy | |
| 07:44 | Colgate | Tommy Klopfenstein makes the free throw | 16-21 |
| 07:15 | Seton Hall | Andrew Pelkey misses long on a 3 from straight away | 16-21 |
| 07:14 | Colgate | Keith Morning pulls down the rebound | 16-21 |
| Lineup | Seton Hall | PG - Andrew Pelkey (tired) 2 ast. SG - Zachariah Randle (tiring) 1 pts. 2 reb. SF - Roger Valera (tiring) 3 pts. PF - Erik Sullivan (fresh) 2 pts. C - Michael Knupp (fresh) 4 pts. 4 reb. | |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Jim Eliason (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SG - Tommy Klopfenstein (fairly fresh) 6 pts. 1 ast. SF - Jim Kloss (fairly fresh) 2 reb. PF - Keith Morning (fairly fresh) 6 pts. 4 reb. C - Clarence Glass (fresh) | |
| 06:58 | Colgate | Jim Kloss dunks the ball on a great pass from Tommy Klopfenstein | 16-23 |
| 06:44 | Seton Hall | Zachariah Randle misses long on a shot in the paint | 16-23 |
| 06:42 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp pulls down the offensive rebound | 16-23 |
| 06:31 | Seton Hall | Tommy Klopfenstein steals it from Andrew Pelkey | 16-23 |
| 06:27 | Colgate | Jim Eliason lays it in on a nice dish by Tommy Klopfenstein | 16-25 |
| 06:16 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp hits the finger roll | 18-25 |
| 05:59 | Colgate | Jim Eliason clanks a 3 pointer from the left wing but the foul's on Michael Knupp - foul #1 on Michael Knupp, team foul #9 | 18-25 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Lloyd Peeler (C) Michael Knupp | |
| Subs | Colgate | Thomas Barnes (PG), Jerry Quintanar (SF), Enlai Ximines (C) Tommy Klopfenstein, Jim Kloss, Clarence Glass | |
| 05:59 | Colgate | Jim Eliason makes the 1st free throw | 18-26 |
| 05:59 | Colgate | Jim Eliason misses the 2nd free throw | 18-26 |
| 05:59 | Colgate | Jim Eliason misses the 3rd free throw | 18-26 |
| 05:59 | Seton Hall | Erik Sullivan grabs the defensive rebound | 18-26 |
| 05:54 | Seton Hall | Enlai Ximines steals it from Zachariah Randle | 18-26 |
| 05:41 | Colgate | Erik Sullivan steals it from Thomas Barnes | 18-26 |
| 05:21 | Seton Hall | Lloyd Peeler loses the dribble to Jim Eliason | 18-26 |
| 05:08 | Colgate | Erik Sullivan steals the ball from Enlai Ximines | 18-26 |
| 04:48 | Seton Hall | Lloyd Peeler misses short on a pull-up jumper from just outside the lane | 18-26 |
| 04:47 | Colgate | Jerry Quintanar grabs the defensive rebound | 18-26 |
| 04:42 | Colgate | Thomas Barnes comes up short on the jumper from the right side but the foul's on Andrew Pelkey - foul #2 on Andrew Pelkey, team foul #10 | 18-26 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Edward Baker (PG) Andrew Pelkey | |
| Subs | Colgate | Jim Kloss (SF), Paul Nagy (PF) Jim Eliason, Keith Morning | |
| 04:42 | Colgate | Thomas Barnes makes the 1st free throw | 18-27 |
| 04:42 | Colgate | Thomas Barnes makes the 2nd free throw | 18-28 |
| 04:22 | Seton Hall | Roger Valera double dribbles | 18-28 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | | |
| Subs | Colgate | Clarence Glass (SF) Jim Kloss | |
| 04:11 | Colgate | Thomas Barnes misses long on a fadeaway jumper from the right wing | 18-28 |
| 04:10 | Colgate | Jerry Quintanar tips it but misses | 18-28 |
| 04:09 | Seton Hall | Erik Sullivan gets the rebound | 18-28 |
| 04:05 | Seton Hall | Zachariah Randle's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 18-28 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | | |
| Subs | Colgate | Tommy Klopfenstein (SG) Enlai Ximines | |
| 03:49 | Colgate | Jerry Quintanar misses long on a floater from the right side | 18-28 |
| 03:48 | Colgate | Jerry Quintanar pulls down the offensive rebound | 18-28 |
| 03:27 | Colgate | Lloyd Peeler takes the ball from Tommy Klopfenstein | 18-28 |
| 03:10 | Seton Hall | Roger Valera is fouled on the floor by Tommy Klopfenstein - foul #2 on Tommy Klopfenstein, team foul #6 | 18-28 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Travis Leyva (SG), Michael Knupp (PF), Oscar Dicks (C) Zachariah Randle, Erik Sullivan, Lloyd Peeler | |
| Subs | Colgate | Anderson Hartman (PG), Jim Kloss (SF), Ronnie Bradley (C) Thomas Barnes, Jerry Quintanar, Clarence Glass | |
| Lineup | Seton Hall | PG - Edward Baker (fresh) 2 pts. SG - Travis Leyva (fresh) 2 pts. SF - Roger Valera (tired) 3 pts. PF - Michael Knupp (fresh) 6 pts. 5 reb. C - Oscar Dicks (fresh) 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Anderson Hartman (fresh) SG - Tommy Klopfenstein (fresh) 6 pts. 3 ast. SF - Jim Kloss (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. PF - Paul Nagy (fresh) 3 pts. 4 reb. C - Ronnie Bradley (fresh) | |
| 02:53 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp misses long on a shot near the basket but he's hacked by Jim Kloss - foul #2 on Jim Kloss, team foul #7 | 18-28 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | | |
| Subs | Colgate | Jim Eliason (PG) Anderson Hartman | |
| 02:53 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp makes the 1st free throw | 19-28 |
| 02:53 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp makes the 2nd free throw | 20-28 |
| 02:36 | Colgate | Jim Kloss hits the finger roll set up by Tommy Klopfenstein and he's hacked by Travis Leyva - foul #3 on Travis Leyva, team foul #11 | 20-30 |
| Subs | Seton Hall | Andrew Pelkey (PG) Travis Leyva | |
| Subs | Colgate | Anderson Hartman (PG), Enlai Ximines (PF) Tommy Klopfenstein, Paul Nagy | |
| 02:36 | Colgate | Jim Kloss misses the free throw | 20-30 |
| 02:36 | Seton Hall | Oscar Dicks snags the defensive board | 20-30 |
| 02:32 | Seton Hall | Andrew Pelkey connects on the floater from just outside the lane | 22-30 |
| 02:13 | Colgate | Ronnie Bradley misses badly on a jump hook from close range | 22-30 |
| 02:12 | Seton Hall | The rebound goes to Michael Knupp | 22-30 |
| 02:07 | Seton Hall | Edward Baker clanks a 3pt shot from the left wing | 22-30 |
| 02:05 | Seton Hall | Oscar Dicks tips it in | 24-30 |
| 01:39 | Colgate | Ronnie Bradley misses short on a 3pt shot from straight away | 24-30 |
| 01:38 | Seton Hall | The rebound goes to Michael Knupp | 24-30 |
| 01:33 | Seton Hall | Edward Baker clanks a floater from the right side | 24-30 |
| 01:31 | Seton Hall | Oscar Dicks grabs the offensive rebound | 24-30 |
| 01:13 | Seton Hall | Andrew Pelkey hits a 3 from the left wing | 27-30 |
| 00:54 | Colgate | Enlai Ximines drills a jumper from the left block set up by Jim Eliason | 27-32 |
| 00:41 | Seton Hall | Enlai Ximines takes the ball from Oscar Dicks | 27-32 |
| 00:34 | Colgate | Ronnie Bradley connects on the 3pt jumper from the left wing | 27-35 |
| 00:27 | Seton Hall | The short jumper by Roger Valera is denied by Jim Kloss | 27-35 |
| 00:26 | Seton Hall | Michael Knupp snags the offensive board | 27-35 |
| 00:04 | Seton Hall | Roger Valera connects on the 3pt attempt from the right wing on a great pass from Michael Knupp | 30-35 |
| 00:00 | Colgate | Jim Kloss hits the front of the rim on the halfcourt shot | 30-35 |