| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Casey Morgan (fresh) SG - David Butler (fresh) SF - Neal Berry (fresh) PF - Ronald Ricca (fresh) C - Lonny Parramore (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Ralph Bristol (fresh) SG - Shelby Coppola (fresh) SF - Anthony Leslie (fresh) PF - William Hunter (fresh) C - Cody Harrison (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | Muskingum | Lonny Parramore wins the tip | 0-0 |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense and a man to man (0) | |
| Game Plan | Otterbein | Otterbein is playing a fastbreak offense and a fullcourt press (0) | |
| 19:39 | Muskingum | Ronald Ricca knocks in the jump hook from the right block set up by David Butler | 2-0 |
| 19:26 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison's fadeaway is rejected by Neal Berry | 2-0 |
| 19:24 | Muskingum | Lonny Parramore grabs the board | 2-0 |
| 19:20 | Muskingum | Cody Harrison swats the layup by Neal Berry | 2-0 |
| 19:19 | Muskingum | Ronald Ricca hits the follow up shot | 4-0 |
| 18:55 | Otterbein | Ronald Ricca blocks the short jumper by William Hunter | 4-0 |
| 18:54 | Muskingum | Neal Berry gets the rebound | 4-0 |
| 18:36 | Muskingum | Neal Berry is alone and drills a fadeaway near the basket on a nice dish by Casey Morgan | 6-0 |
| 18:21 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol misses short on a jumpshot from just outside the lane | 6-0 |
| 18:20 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to David Butler | 6-0 |
| 18:18 | Muskingum | Casey Morgan is whistled for traveling in the backcourt | 6-0 |
| 18:01 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison drills a turnaround in the lane on a nice dish by Anthony Leslie | 6-2 |
| 17:39 | Muskingum | Neal Berry misses badly on a fadeaway from close range but he's fouled by Anthony Leslie - foul #1 on Anthony Leslie, team foul #1 | 6-2 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Guthrie (PG), Paul Dorsey (SG), Mark Chea (PF), James Robertson (C) Casey Morgan, David Butler, Ronald Ricca, Lonny Parramore | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin (PG), Edward Green (SF), Chad Marquardt (PF), Clarence Hutcherson (C) Ralph Bristol, Anthony Leslie, William Hunter, Cody Harrison | |
| 17:39 | Muskingum | Neal Berry makes the 1st free throw | 7-2 |
| 17:39 | Muskingum | Neal Berry makes the 2nd free throw | 8-2 |
| 17:18 | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson drills a floater from the right side | 8-4 |
| 17:12 | Muskingum | A charge is called on James Robertson - foul #1 on James Robertson, team foul #1 | 8-4 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Nathan Beatty (C) Neal Berry | |
| Subs | Otterbein | James Hamberg (SG) Shelby Coppola | |
| 16:48 | Otterbein | James Robertson steals the ball from Edward Green | 8-4 |
| 16:45 | Muskingum | James Robertson jams it | 10-4 |
| 16:22 | Otterbein | Edward Green comes up short on the 3pt jumper from straight away | 10-4 |
| 16:20 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey pulls down the rebound | 10-4 |
| 16:01 | Muskingum | Nathan Beatty can't connect on a 3pt jumper from the left wing | 10-4 |
| 15:59 | Otterbein | Chad Marquardt snags the defensive board | 10-4 |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - James Guthrie (fairly fresh) SG - Paul Dorsey (fairly fresh) SF - James Robertson (fairly fresh) 2 pts. PF - Mark Chea (fairly fresh) C - Nathan Beatty (fairly fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Ralph Griffin (fairly fresh) SG - James Hamberg (fresh) SF - Edward Green (fairly fresh) PF - Chad Marquardt (fairly fresh) C - Clarence Hutcherson (fairly fresh) 2 pts. | |
| 15:53 | Otterbein | Edward Green can't connect on a driving attempt from the baseline but the foul's on Paul Dorsey - foul #1 on Paul Dorsey, team foul #2 | 10-4 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Casey Morgan (PG), David Butler (SG), James Knotts (SF), Ronald Ricca (PF), Lonny Parramore (C) James Guthrie, Paul Dorsey, James Robertson, Mark Chea, Nathan Beatty | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol (PG), Shelby Coppola (SG), William Hunter (PF), Cody Harrison (C) Ralph Griffin, James Hamberg, Chad Marquardt, Clarence Hutcherson | |
| 15:53 | Otterbein | Edward Green misses the 1st free throw | 10-4 |
| 15:53 | Otterbein | Edward Green misses the 2nd free throw | 10-4 |
| 15:53 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison grabs the offensive board | 10-4 |
| 15:36 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola is fouled on the floor by Ronald Ricca - foul #1 on Ronald Ricca, team foul #3 | 10-4 |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Anthony Leslie (SF) Edward Green | |
| 15:22 | Otterbein | Anthony Leslie drills a turnaround from the baseline set up by Cody Harrison | 10-6 |
| 15:18 | Muskingum | David Butler hits a 3pt shot from the left wing set up by Casey Morgan | 13-6 |
| 15:14 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol loses the ball out of bounds | 13-6 |
| 15:03 | Muskingum | James Knotts is fouled on the floor by Ralph Bristol - foul #1 on Ralph Bristol, team foul #2 | 13-6 |
| 14:54 | Muskingum | Lonny Parramore misses badly on a 3pt shot from the right corner | 13-6 |
| 14:53 | Muskingum | The offensive rebound goes to Lonny Parramore | 13-6 |
| 14:44 | Muskingum | Lonny Parramore misses badly on a 3 pointer from straight away | 13-6 |
| 14:43 | Muskingum | Ronald Ricca hits the follow up shot | 15-6 |
| 14:20 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison hits a driving attempt from the baseline on a great pass from Ralph Bristol and he's hacked by Ronald Ricca - foul #2 on Ronald Ricca, team foul #4 | 15-8 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey (PG), Neal Berry (SF), Nathan Beatty (C) Casey Morgan, Ronald Ricca, Lonny Parramore | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett (PG), James Hamberg (SG), Chad Marquardt (PF) Ralph Bristol, Shelby Coppola, William Hunter | |
| 14:20 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison misses the free throw | 15-8 |
| 14:20 | Muskingum | Nathan Beatty gets the rebound | 15-8 |
| 14:16 | Muskingum | James Hamberg steals the ball from Nathan Beatty in the backcourt | 15-8 |
| 14:03 | Otterbein | Chad Marquardt makes the floater from close range set up by James Hamberg | 15-10 |
| 14:00 | Muskingum | David Butler is fouled in the backcourt by James Hamberg - foul #1 on James Hamberg, team foul #3 | 15-10 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Robertson (PF) James Knotts | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin (SG), Clarence Hutcherson (C) Anthony Leslie, Cody Harrison | |
| 13:48 | Muskingum | Ralph Griffin picks off the pass by Nathan Beatty | 15-10 |
| 13:32 | Otterbein | James Hamberg misses short on a floater from the free throw line | 15-10 |
| 13:31 | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson pulls down the offensive rebound | 15-10 |
| 13:19 | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett is fouled on the floor by Neal Berry - foul #1 on Neal Berry, team foul #5 | 15-10 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Guthrie (PG), Mark Chea (PF) David Butler, Nathan Beatty | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Anthony Leslie (SF), William Hunter (PF) James Hamberg, Clarence Hutcherson | |
| 12:59 | Otterbein | Anthony Leslie misses short on a 3 pointer from the left corner | 15-10 |
| 12:57 | Otterbein | William Hunter pulls down the offensive rebound | 15-10 |
| 12:46 | Otterbein | Chad Marquardt steps out of bounds on the baseline | 15-10 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Knotts (SG), Lonny Parramore (C) Paul Dorsey, James Robertson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol (PG), Shelby Coppola (SG), Edward Green (SF), Cody Harrison (C) Jerome Pritchett, Ralph Griffin, Anthony Leslie, Chad Marquardt | |
| 12:25 | Muskingum | Neal Berry hits a 3pt attempt from the right wing on a great pass from James Guthrie | 18-10 |
| 12:10 | Otterbein | William Hunter is fouled on the floor by Mark Chea - foul #1 on Mark Chea, team foul #6 | 18-10 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Casey Morgan (PG), David Butler (SG) James Guthrie, Mark Chea | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson (C) Cody Harrison | |
| 11:52 | Otterbein | William Hunter can't finish the layup but the foul's on James Knotts - foul #1 on James Knotts, team foul #7 | 18-10 |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Henry Newbury (PG), James Hamberg (SF) Ralph Bristol, Edward Green | |
| 11:52 | Otterbein | William Hunter misses the 1st free throw | 18-10 |
| 11:52 | Otterbein | William Hunter makes the 2nd free throw | 18-11 |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Casey Morgan (fresh) 2 ast. SG - David Butler (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SF - Neal Berry (fairly fresh) 7 pts. PF - James Knotts (fresh) C - Lonny Parramore (fresh) 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Henry Newbury (fresh) SG - Shelby Coppola (fresh) SF - James Hamberg (fresh) PF - William Hunter (fairly fresh) 1 pts. C - Clarence Hutcherson (fresh) 2 pts. | |
| 11:32 | Muskingum | Casey Morgan misses the 3 pointer from the right wing | 18-11 |
| 11:31 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Clarence Hutcherson | 18-11 |
| 11:27 | Otterbein | James Hamberg buries a 3pt jumper from straight away set up by Shelby Coppola | 18-14 |
| 11:09 | Muskingum | Neal Berry is wide open but clanks a 3pt attempt from the right corner | 18-14 |
| 11:08 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to William Hunter | 18-14 |
| 11:02 | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson misses long on a jumper near the basket | 18-14 |
| 11:01 | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson hits the follow up shot | 18-16 |
| 10:52 | Muskingum | Henry Newbury steals it from Casey Morgan | 18-16 |
| 10:41 | Otterbein | William Hunter is called for a charge - foul #1 on William Hunter, team foul #4 | 18-16 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey (SG), James Robertson (SF), Mark Chea (PF), Nathan Beatty (C) David Butler, Neal Berry, James Knotts, Lonny Parramore | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol (PG), Ralph Griffin (SG), Jerome Pritchett (SF), Chad Marquardt (PF), Cody Harrison (C) Henry Newbury, Shelby Coppola, James Hamberg, William Hunter, Clarence Hutcherson | |
| 10:28 | Muskingum | Ralph Griffin is called for the reach on Paul Dorsey - foul #1 on Ralph Griffin, team foul #5 | 18-16 |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Anthony Leslie (SF) Jerome Pritchett | |
| 10:13 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey misses short on a shot from the right side but he's fouled by Cody Harrison - foul #1 on Cody Harrison, team foul #6 | 18-16 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Guthrie (PG) Casey Morgan | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 10:13 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey misses the 1st free throw | 18-16 |
| 10:13 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey makes the 2nd free throw | 19-16 |
| 10:00 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison misses long on a driving attempt from close range | 19-16 |
| 09:58 | Muskingum | James Robertson snags the defensive board | 19-16 |
| 09:45 | Muskingum | James Guthrie misses badly on a jumper from the left wing | 19-16 |
| 09:44 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison pulls down the rebound | 19-16 |
| 09:40 | Otterbein | James Robertson steps in front of the Anthony Leslie pass | 19-16 |
| 09:36 | Muskingum | The jumper by Paul Dorsey is denied by Cody Harrison | 19-16 |
| 09:35 | Muskingum | Mark Chea grabs the offensive rebound | 19-16 |
| 09:17 | Muskingum | James Robertson scores on a driving attempt from close range | 21-16 |
| 09:11 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison misses long on a jumper near the basket | 21-16 |
| 09:10 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey gets the rebound | 21-16 |
| 08:50 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey knocks in the floater from the free throw line on a nice dish by James Robertson | 23-16 |
| 08:40 | Otterbein | Anthony Leslie is hacked by James Robertson - foul #2 on James Robertson, team foul #8 | 23-16 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Casey Morgan (PG), David Butler (SG), Neal Berry (SF), James Knotts (PF), Lonny Parramore (C) James Guthrie, Paul Dorsey, James Robertson, Mark Chea, Nathan Beatty | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett (PG), Shelby Coppola (SG), Clarence Hutcherson (PF), Edward Green (C) Ralph Bristol, Ralph Griffin, Chad Marquardt, Cody Harrison | |
| 08:40 | Otterbein | Anthony Leslie makes the 1st free throw | 23-17 |
| 08:40 | Otterbein | Anthony Leslie makes the 2nd free throw | 23-18 |
| 08:20 | Muskingum | Lonny Parramore misses long on a shot from close range | 23-18 |
| 08:18 | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett gets the rebound | 23-18 |
| 08:13 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola can't connect on a fadeaway from the left side | 23-18 |
| 08:11 | Muskingum | Lonny Parramore grabs the board | 23-18 |
| 08:08 | Muskingum | Jerome Pritchett takes the ball from Neal Berry in the backcourt | 23-18 |
| 08:06 | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett lays it up and in | 23-20 |
| 07:56 | Muskingum | Shelby Coppola steps in front of the Casey Morgan pass | 23-20 |
| 07:53 | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett misses the lay-in | 23-20 |
| 07:52 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to Lonny Parramore | 23-20 |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Casey Morgan (fairly fresh) 2 ast. SG - David Butler (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SF - Neal Berry (fairly fresh) 7 pts. PF - James Knotts (fresh) C - Lonny Parramore (fresh) 4 reb. | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Jerome Pritchett (fresh) 2 pts. SG - Shelby Coppola (fresh) 1 ast. SF - Anthony Leslie (tiring) 4 pts. PF - Clarence Hutcherson (fresh) 4 pts. 3 reb. C - Edward Green (fresh) | |
| 07:38 | Muskingum | David Butler makes the wide open 3pt jumper from the left corner on a nice dish by Casey Morgan | 26-20 |
| 07:24 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola is called for traveling | 26-20 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey (SF), Mark Chea (PF) Neal Berry, James Knotts | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Henry Newbury (PG), James Hamberg (SF), William Hunter (PF), Cody Harrison (C) Jerome Pritchett, Anthony Leslie, Clarence Hutcherson, Edward Green | |
| 07:22 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey's pass is off the mark and out of bounds in the backcourt | 26-20 |
| 07:05 | Otterbein | William Hunter lays it in | 26-22 |
| 06:46 | Muskingum | David Butler misses short on a 3 pointer from straight away | 26-22 |
| 06:44 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Henry Newbury | 26-22 |
| 06:38 | Otterbein | James Hamberg misses badly on a turnaround from close range | 26-22 |
| 06:36 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola snags the offensive board | 26-22 |
| 06:09 | Otterbein | William Hunter hits a jump hook from the left block | 26-24 |
| 05:55 | Muskingum | Mark Chea connects on the fadeaway in the lane set up by Casey Morgan and the foul's on William Hunter - foul #2 on William Hunter, team foul #7 | 28-24 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Guthrie (PG), James Knotts (SG), Neal Berry (SF), Nathan Beatty (C) Casey Morgan, David Butler, Paul Dorsey, Lonny Parramore | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol (PG), Ralph Griffin (SG), Edward Green (SF), Chad Marquardt (PF), Clarence Hutcherson (C) Henry Newbury, Shelby Coppola, James Hamberg, William Hunter, Cody Harrison | |
| 05:55 | Muskingum | Mark Chea makes the free throw | 29-24 |
| 05:38 | Otterbein | Neal Berry is called for the reach on Ralph Griffin - foul #2 on Neal Berry, team foul #9 | 29-24 |
| Subs | Muskingum | David Butler (SG) Neal Berry | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 05:38 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin makes the 1st free throw | 29-25 |
| 05:38 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin misses the 2nd free throw | 29-25 |
| 05:38 | Otterbein | Chad Marquardt snags the offensive board | 29-25 |
| 05:29 | Otterbein | Chad Marquardt's fadeaway is rejected by James Knotts | 29-25 |
| 05:28 | Muskingum | Nathan Beatty grabs the board | 29-25 |
| 05:17 | Muskingum | Nathan Beatty hits the front of the rim on the 3pt attempt from the right wing | 29-25 |
| 05:16 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin grabs the defensive rebound | 29-25 |
| 05:10 | Otterbein | Edward Green double dribbles | 29-25 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey (SF), Lonny Parramore (C) Mark Chea, Nathan Beatty | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett (SF), Cody Harrison (C) Edward Green, Clarence Hutcherson | |
| 05:00 | Muskingum | James Knotts makes the fadeaway jumper from the left side on a nice dish by James Guthrie | 31-25 |
| 04:36 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin misses long on a 3 from the left corner | 31-25 |
| 04:35 | Muskingum | James Guthrie pulls down the rebound | 31-25 |
| 04:13 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey misses long on an open jumper from just outside the lane | 31-25 |
| 04:12 | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett grabs the board | 31-25 |
| 04:07 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol drills a floater from the right wing on a nice dish by Ralph Griffin | 31-27 |
| 03:49 | Muskingum | A charge is called on Lonny Parramore - foul #1 on Lonny Parramore, team foul #10 | 31-27 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Casey Morgan (PG), James Robertson (SF), Ronald Ricca (PF), Nathan Beatty (C) James Guthrie, Paul Dorsey, James Knotts, Lonny Parramore | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Henry Newbury (PG), Shelby Coppola (SG), James Hamberg (SF), William Hunter (PF), Clarence Hutcherson (C) Ralph Bristol, Ralph Griffin, Jerome Pritchett, Chad Marquardt, Cody Harrison | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Casey Morgan (fairly fresh) 4 ast. SG - David Butler (fairly fresh) 6 pts. 1 ast. SF - James Robertson (fresh) 4 pts. 2 stl. PF - Ronald Ricca (fresh) 6 pts. 2 reb. C - Nathan Beatty (fresh) 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Henry Newbury (fresh) SG - Shelby Coppola (fresh) 1 ast. SF - James Hamberg (fresh) 3 pts. PF - William Hunter (fresh) 5 pts. 2 reb. C - Clarence Hutcherson (fresh) 4 pts. 3 reb. | |
| 03:37 | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson's floater is tipped away by Ronald Ricca | 31-27 |
| 03:35 | Muskingum | James Robertson pulls down the rebound | 31-27 |
| 03:12 | Muskingum | James Robertson buries a 3pt attempt from straight away on a nice dish by Casey Morgan | 34-27 |
| 02:49 | Otterbein | Ronald Ricca denies the turnaround by Henry Newbury | 34-27 |
| 02:47 | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson misses the tip | 34-27 |
| 02:45 | Muskingum | James Robertson grabs the defensive rebound | 34-27 |
| 02:43 | Muskingum | Casey Morgan is called for the offensive foul in the backcourt - foul #1 on Casey Morgan, team foul #11 | 34-27 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Neal Berry (SF) Nathan Beatty | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol (PG), Edward Green (SF), Chad Marquardt (C) Henry Newbury, James Hamberg, Clarence Hutcherson | |
| 02:32 | Otterbein | Ronald Ricca blocks the jumper by William Hunter | 34-27 |
| 02:30 | Muskingum | Neal Berry grabs the board | 34-27 |
| 02:24 | Muskingum | James Robertson is fouled on the floor by Shelby Coppola - foul #1 on Shelby Coppola, team foul #8 | 34-27 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey (SG) David Butler | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett (PG) Ralph Bristol | |
| 02:24 | Muskingum | James Robertson makes the 1st free throw | 35-27 |
| 02:24 | Muskingum | James Robertson makes the 2nd free throw | 36-27 |
| 02:13 | Otterbein | William Hunter misses short on a runner from the baseline | 36-27 |
| 02:11 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola hits the follow up shot | 36-29 |
| 02:00 | Muskingum | James Robertson can't connect on a jumpshot from the right wing | 36-29 |
| 01:59 | Otterbein | Edward Green grabs the defensive rebound | 36-29 |
| 01:55 | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett comes up short on the 3 pointer from the left corner | 36-29 |
| 01:53 | Otterbein | Edward Green pulls down the offensive rebound | 36-29 |
| 01:48 | Otterbein | William Hunter is fouled on the floor by James Robertson - foul #3 on James Robertson, team foul #12 | 36-29 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Guthrie (PG), James Knotts (SG), Lonny Parramore (C) Casey Morgan, Paul Dorsey, James Robertson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol (PG), Anthony Leslie (SF) Jerome Pritchett, Chad Marquardt | |
| 01:48 | Otterbein | William Hunter makes the 1st free throw | 36-30 |
| 01:48 | Otterbein | William Hunter makes the 2nd free throw | 36-31 |
| 01:20 | Muskingum | Neal Berry is fouled on the floor by Anthony Leslie - foul #2 on Anthony Leslie, team foul #9 | 36-31 |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | James Hamberg (SG), Clarence Hutcherson (C) Shelby Coppola, Edward Green | |
| 01:20 | Muskingum | Neal Berry makes the 1st free throw | 37-31 |
| 01:20 | Muskingum | Neal Berry misses the 2nd free throw | 37-31 |
| 01:20 | Otterbein | William Hunter snags the defensive board | 37-31 |
| 00:57 | Otterbein | Lonny Parramore is called for the reach on Clarence Hutcherson - foul #2 on Lonny Parramore, team foul #13 | 37-31 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Casey Morgan (PG), David Butler (SG) James Guthrie, James Knotts | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Cody Harrison (C) William Hunter | |
| 00:57 | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson makes the 1st free throw | 37-32 |
| 00:57 | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson misses the 2nd free throw | 37-32 |
| 00:57 | Muskingum | Ronald Ricca gets the rebound | 37-32 |
| 00:45 | Muskingum | Ronald Ricca's floater is tipped away by Clarence Hutcherson | 37-32 |
| 00:44 | Muskingum | Lonny Parramore tips it home | 39-32 |
| 00:19 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol throws a bad pass out of bounds | 39-32 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey (SG), Nathan Beatty (C) David Butler, Lonny Parramore | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett (PG), Ralph Griffin (SG), William Hunter (PF) Ralph Bristol, James Hamberg, Clarence Hutcherson | |
| 00:17 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey is hacked by Ralph Griffin in the backcourt - foul #2 on Ralph Griffin, team foul #10 | 39-32 |
| 00:17 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey misses the 1st free throw | 39-32 |
| 00:17 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey misses the 2nd free throw | 39-32 |
| 00:17 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison snags the defensive board | 39-32 |
| 00:05 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison hits the finger roll on a nice dish by Ralph Griffin and he's hacked by Nathan Beatty - foul #1 on Nathan Beatty, team foul #14 | 39-34 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Knotts (SG) Casey Morgan | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Chad Marquardt (PF) William Hunter | |
| 00:05 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison makes the free throw | 39-35 |
| 00:03 | Muskingum | Ralph Griffin steps in front of the James Knotts pass in the backcourt | 39-35 |
| 00:01 | Otterbein | Anthony Leslie misses the pull-up jumper from the left wing | 39-35 |
| 00:00 | Muskingum | Paul Dorsey grabs the defensive rebound | 39-35 |
| 00:00 | Muskingum | The refs have stopped play. Nathan Beatty is in a lot of pain and is being checked by the trainers. His finger is completely bent. He appears to have just been shaken up and should be able to return. | 39-35 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Lonny Parramore (C) Nathan Beatty | |
| Subs | Otterbein | William Hunter (PF) Cody Harrison | |