| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Ralph Bristol (fresh) SG - Shelby Coppola (fresh) SF - James Hamberg (fresh) PF - Edward Green (fresh) C - Cody Harrison (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Shenandoah | PG - Buford Schmidt (fresh) SG - Charles Barlow (fresh) SF - Johnnie Thompson (fresh) PF - Eric Benito (fresh) C - Jack Seavey (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison wins the tip | 0-0 |
| Game Plan | Otterbein | Otterbein is playing a fastbreak offense and a fullcourt press (0) | |
| Game Plan | Shenandoah | Shenandoah is playing a motion offense and a fullcourt press (0) | |
| 19:45 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol clanks a 3pt attempt from the right corner | 0-0 |
| 19:43 | Shenandoah | Eric Benito grabs the defensive rebound | 0-0 |
| 19:21 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson scores on a 3pt jumper from the left corner on a nice dish by Buford Schmidt | 0-3 |
| 19:16 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola misses badly on a shot from just outside the lane | 0-3 |
| 19:15 | Shenandoah | Buford Schmidt grabs the defensive rebound | 0-3 |
| 18:51 | Shenandoah | Jack Seavey knocks in the 3 from the right wing on a nice dish by Buford Schmidt | 0-6 |
| 18:48 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol double dribbles in the backcourt | 0-6 |
| 18:32 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson clanks a 3pt jumper from the right wing | 0-6 |
| 18:31 | Shenandoah | Eric Benito grabs the offensive board | 0-6 |
| 18:10 | Shenandoah | Buford Schmidt is open and scores on a jumpshot from the left wing set up by Charles Barlow | 0-8 |
| 18:08 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol's pass is intercepted by Charles Barlow in the backcourt | 0-8 |
| 17:51 | Shenandoah | Buford Schmidt misses long on a floater from the free throw line | 0-8 |
| 17:50 | Otterbein | Edward Green pulls down the rebound | 0-8 |
| 17:44 | Otterbein | Edward Green comes up short on the fadeaway jumper from the right wing | 0-8 |
| 17:43 | Shenandoah | The rebound goes to Jack Seavey | 0-8 |
| 17:41 | Shenandoah | Shelby Coppola is called for the reach on Buford Schmidt in the backcourt - foul #1 on Shelby Coppola, team foul #1 | 0-8 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin (PG), Jerome Pritchett (SG), Allan Mason (SF), Clarence Hutcherson (PF), Chad Marquardt (C) Ralph Bristol, Shelby Coppola, James Hamberg, Edward Green, Cody Harrison | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | James Newcomb (PG), Johnny Snodgrass (SG), Frederick Cox (SF), Andrew Weiner (PF), Albert Shook (C) Buford Schmidt, Charles Barlow, Johnnie Thompson, Eric Benito, Jack Seavey | |
| 17:26 | Shenandoah | Andrew Weiner makes the driving attempt in the lane | 0-10 |
| 17:05 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin hits the front of the rim on the jumper from close range | 0-10 |
| 17:03 | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett tips it but misses | 0-10 |
| 17:02 | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass snags the defensive board | 0-10 |
| 16:58 | Shenandoah | James Newcomb is fouled in the backcourt by Ralph Griffin - foul #1 on Ralph Griffin, team foul #2 | 0-10 |
| 16:50 | Shenandoah | Frederick Cox misses the jump hook in the paint | 0-10 |
| 16:48 | Shenandoah | Albert Shook grabs the offensive board | 0-10 |
| 16:24 | Shenandoah | James Newcomb can't connect on a 3 from the left wing | 0-10 |
| 16:22 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin pulls down the rebound | 0-10 |
| 16:02 | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson travels with the ball | 0-10 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Henry Newbury (PG), Shelby Coppola (SG), Jeffrey Berkey (SF), Edward Green (PF), Cody Harrison (C) Ralph Griffin, Jerome Pritchett, Allan Mason, Clarence Hutcherson, Chad Marquardt | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Buford Schmidt (PG), Charles Barlow (SG), Johnnie Thompson (SF), Stephen French (PF), Jack Seavey (C) James Newcomb, Johnny Snodgrass, Frederick Cox, Andrew Weiner, Albert Shook | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Henry Newbury (fresh) SG - Shelby Coppola (fairly fresh) SF - Jeffrey Berkey (fresh) PF - Edward Green (fairly fresh) C - Cody Harrison (fairly fresh) | |
| Lineup | Shenandoah | PG - Buford Schmidt (fresh) 2 pts. 2 ast. SG - Charles Barlow (fresh) 1 ast. SF - Johnnie Thompson (fresh) 3 pts. PF - Stephen French (fresh) C - Jack Seavey (fresh) 3 pts. | |
| 15:47 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow is open but misses the lay-in | 0-10 |
| 15:46 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola snags the defensive board | 0-10 |
| 15:42 | Otterbein | Stephen French steals it from Henry Newbury | 0-10 |
| 15:24 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow is called for 5 seconds | 0-10 |
| 15:14 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola hits the front of the rim on the 3 pointer from straight away | 0-10 |
| 15:12 | Otterbein | Edward Green gets the offensive rebound | 0-10 |
| 15:01 | Otterbein | Jack Seavey picks off the pass by Shelby Coppola | 0-10 |
| 14:59 | Shenandoah | Cody Harrison steals the ball from Buford Schmidt in the backcourt | 0-10 |
| 14:37 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola comes up short on the shot from the left block | 0-10 |
| 14:36 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow snags the defensive board | 0-10 |
| 14:31 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow is by himself and knocks in the jumper from close range set up by Buford Schmidt | 0-12 |
| 14:09 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola misses the wide open 3pt attempt from the right wing | 0-12 |
| 14:08 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson grabs the board | 0-12 |
| 13:47 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow's pass is intercepted by Henry Newbury | 0-12 |
| 13:44 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola hits the finger roll set up by Henry Newbury | 2-12 |
| 13:28 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 2-12 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol (PG), Jerome Pritchett (SG), James Hamberg (SF), Clarence Hutcherson (PF), Chad Marquardt (C) Henry Newbury, Shelby Coppola, Jeffrey Berkey, Edward Green, Cody Harrison | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | James Newcomb (PG), Johnny Snodgrass (SG), Frederick Cox (SF), Eric Benito (PF), Albert Shook (C) Buford Schmidt, Charles Barlow, Johnnie Thompson, Stephen French, Jack Seavey | |
| 13:14 | Otterbein | The jump hook by Chad Marquardt is blocked by Albert Shook | 2-12 |
| 13:12 | Otterbein | James Hamberg misses the tip | 2-12 |
| 13:11 | Shenandoah | Frederick Cox grabs the defensive rebound | 2-12 |
| 12:49 | Shenandoah | James Hamberg is called for the reach on Frederick Cox - foul #1 on James Hamberg, team foul #3 | 2-12 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin (SG), Allan Mason (SF) Jerome Pritchett, James Hamberg | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Buford Schmidt (PG), Johnnie Thompson (SF) Johnny Snodgrass, Frederick Cox | |
| 12:31 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson is open and buries a runner from the left block on a great pass from Buford Schmidt | 2-14 |
| 12:24 | Otterbein | Chad Marquardt is whistled for traveling | 2-14 |
| Subs | Otterbein | James Hamberg (SF) Chad Marquardt | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Andrew Weiner (SG), Galen Thompson (C) Buford Schmidt, Albert Shook | |
| 12:02 | Shenandoah | Eric Benito hits the front of the rim on the shot from close range | 2-14 |
| 12:01 | Shenandoah | Andrew Weiner tips it back up and in | 2-16 |
| 11:57 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol is fouled in the backcourt by Andrew Weiner - foul #1 on Andrew Weiner, team foul #1 | 2-16 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett (SG), Cody Harrison (C) Ralph Griffin, Allan Mason | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow (SG) Eric Benito | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Ralph Bristol (fairly fresh) SG - Jerome Pritchett (fresh) SF - James Hamberg (fairly fresh) PF - Clarence Hutcherson (fairly fresh) C - Cody Harrison (tiring) | |
| Lineup | Shenandoah | PG - James Newcomb (fairly fresh) SG - Charles Barlow (tiring) 2 pts. 1 ast. SF - Johnnie Thompson (tiring) 5 pts. PF - Andrew Weiner (fresh) 4 pts. C - Galen Thompson (fresh) | |
| 11:43 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison comes up short on the shot from close range | 2-16 |
| 11:41 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson grabs the defensive rebound | 2-16 |
| 11:37 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow misses the lay-in but the foul's on Jerome Pritchett - foul #1 on Jerome Pritchett, team foul #4 | 2-16 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Buford Schmidt (PG), Frederick Cox (PF) Johnnie Thompson, Andrew Weiner | |
| 11:37 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow makes the 1st free throw | 2-17 |
| 11:37 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow misses the 2nd free throw | 2-17 |
| 11:37 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison snags the defensive board | 2-17 |
| 11:28 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison hits the front of the rim on the fadeaway in the paint | 2-17 |
| 11:26 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol gets the offensive rebound | 2-17 |
| 11:07 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol misses short on a jumpshot from the left side but the foul's on Frederick Cox - foul #1 on Frederick Cox, team foul #2 | 2-17 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola (SG), Edward Green (PF), Chad Marquardt (C) Jerome Pritchett, Clarence Hutcherson, Cody Harrison | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass (SG), Eric Benito (PF), Albert Shook (C) Charles Barlow, James Newcomb, Galen Thompson | |
| 11:07 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol makes the 1st free throw | 3-17 |
| 11:07 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol makes the 2nd free throw | 4-17 |
| 10:53 | Shenandoah | Frederick Cox misses the 3 pointer from the right wing | 4-17 |
| 10:51 | Otterbein | Chad Marquardt snags the defensive board | 4-17 |
| 10:45 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola misses the dunk but he's hacked by Johnny Snodgrass - foul #1 on Johnny Snodgrass, team foul #3 | 4-17 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin (PG) Ralph Bristol | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson (SF) Frederick Cox | |
| 10:45 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola makes the 1st free throw | 5-17 |
| 10:45 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola makes the 2nd free throw | 6-17 |
| 10:25 | Shenandoah | Albert Shook drills a jump hook from the left block on a nice dish by Johnny Snodgrass | 6-19 |
| 10:23 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola is called for traveling in the backcourt | 6-19 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson (C) Edward Green | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | James Newcomb (PG), Charles Barlow (SG), Jack Seavey (C) Buford Schmidt, Johnny Snodgrass, Albert Shook | |
| 10:09 | Shenandoah | Jack Seavey clanks a 3 from the right wing | 6-19 |
| 10:07 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson tips it but misses | 6-19 |
| 10:05 | Otterbein | Chad Marquardt grabs the defensive rebound | 6-19 |
| 10:00 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola makes the 3pt shot from the right corner on a nice dish by James Hamberg | 9-19 |
| 09:37 | Shenandoah | Jack Seavey hits a fadeaway from just outside the lane | 9-21 |
| 09:16 | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola misses badly on a shot from the left side | 9-21 |
| 09:14 | Shenandoah | Eric Benito gets the rebound | 9-21 |
| 08:48 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson buries a 3pt attempt from the left wing | 9-24 |
| 08:46 | Otterbein | Otterbein calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 9-24 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Henry Newbury (PG), Jerome Pritchett (SG), Jeffrey Berkey (SF), Allan Mason (PF), Cody Harrison (C) Ralph Griffin, Shelby Coppola, James Hamberg, Chad Marquardt, Clarence Hutcherson | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass (PG), Andrew Weiner (SG), Frederick Cox (SF), Stephen French (PF), Albert Shook (C) James Newcomb, Charles Barlow, Johnnie Thompson, Eric Benito, Jack Seavey | |
| 08:30 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Berkey is open and scores on a fadeaway from the right block set up by Henry Newbury | 11-24 |
| 08:28 | Shenandoah | Frederick Cox loses the dribble to Jerome Pritchett in the backcourt | 11-24 |
| 08:19 | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett misses the 3pt shot from the right corner | 11-24 |
| 08:18 | Shenandoah | Stephen French pulls down the rebound | 11-24 |
| 08:04 | Shenandoah | Albert Shook comes up short on the shot in the lane | 11-24 |
| 08:03 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison pulls down the rebound | 11-24 |
| 07:41 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison drills a jump hook from the baseline and the foul's on Albert Shook - foul #1 on Albert Shook, team foul #4 | 13-24 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol (PG), Shelby Coppola (SG), Edward Green (PF) Henry Newbury, Jeffrey Berkey, Allan Mason | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Buford Schmidt (PG), James Newcomb (SF), Galen Thompson (C) Andrew Weiner, Stephen French, Albert Shook | |
| 07:41 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison makes the free throw | 14-24 |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Ralph Bristol (fairly fresh) 2 pts. SG - Shelby Coppola (tiring) 7 pts. SF - Jerome Pritchett (fairly fresh) PF - Edward Green (tiring) 2 reb. C - Cody Harrison (tiring) 3 pts. 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Shenandoah | PG - Buford Schmidt (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 4 ast. SG - Johnny Snodgrass (fairly fresh) 1 ast. SF - James Newcomb (fairly fresh) PF - Frederick Cox (fairly fresh) C - Galen Thompson (fresh) | |
| 07:18 | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass is fouled on the floor by Shelby Coppola - foul #2 on Shelby Coppola, team foul #5 | 14-24 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Allan Mason (SF) Shelby Coppola | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow (SG), Johnnie Thompson (SF) Johnny Snodgrass, James Newcomb | |
| 07:07 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow loses the ball out of bounds | 14-24 |
| 07:05 | Otterbein | Allan Mason is hacked by Charles Barlow in the backcourt - foul #1 on Charles Barlow, team foul #5 | 14-24 |
| 06:49 | Otterbein | Allan Mason is hacked by Johnnie Thompson - foul #1 on Johnnie Thompson, team foul #6 | 14-24 |
| Subs | Otterbein | James Hamberg (SF), Chad Marquardt (C) Allan Mason, Cody Harrison | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Eric Benito (PF), Jack Seavey (C) Frederick Cox, Galen Thompson | |
| 06:41 | Otterbein | Eric Benito is called for the reach on Edward Green - foul #1 on Eric Benito, team foul #7 | 14-24 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | James Newcomb (SF) Johnnie Thompson | |
| 06:41 | Otterbein | Edward Green misses the 1st free throw | 14-24 |
| 06:41 | Shenandoah | The rebound goes to Jack Seavey | 14-24 |
| 06:22 | Shenandoah | James Newcomb connects on the 3pt attempt from the left wing on a nice dish by Buford Schmidt | 14-27 |
| 06:09 | Otterbein | James Hamberg hits a 3pt attempt from the right corner on a great pass from Jerome Pritchett | 17-27 |
| 05:56 | Shenandoah | James Newcomb can't connect on a 3 pointer from straight away | 17-27 |
| 05:55 | Shenandoah | Eric Benito grabs the offensive rebound | 17-27 |
| 05:39 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow throws a bad pass out of bounds | 17-27 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin (SG), Jeffrey Berkey (SF), Clarence Hutcherson (PF), Cody Harrison (C) Jerome Pritchett, James Hamberg, Edward Green, Chad Marquardt | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass (SG), Johnnie Thompson (SF), Frederick Cox (PF), Albert Shook (C) Charles Barlow, James Newcomb, Eric Benito, Jack Seavey | |
| 05:23 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin is hacked by Johnny Snodgrass - foul #2 on Johnny Snodgrass, team foul #8 | 17-27 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Andrew Weiner (SG) Johnny Snodgrass | |
| 05:23 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin makes the 1st free throw | 18-27 |
| 05:23 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin misses the 2nd free throw | 18-27 |
| 05:23 | Shenandoah | Albert Shook gets the rebound | 18-27 |
| 05:08 | Shenandoah | Frederick Cox hits the front of the rim on the floater from the baseline but the foul's on Ralph Bristol - foul #1 on Ralph Bristol, team foul #6 | 18-27 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Henry Newbury (SG) Ralph Bristol | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | | |
| 05:08 | Shenandoah | Frederick Cox makes the 1st free throw | 18-28 |
| 05:08 | Shenandoah | Frederick Cox makes the 2nd free throw | 18-29 |
| 05:05 | Otterbein | Henry Newbury throws a bad pass out of bounds in the backcourt | 18-29 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | James Newcomb (SG) Frederick Cox | |
| 04:50 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson hits the front of the rim on the 3pt jumper from straight away | 18-29 |
| 04:49 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin grabs the board | 18-29 |
| 04:43 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Berkey connects on the turnaround in the lane on a nice dish by Ralph Griffin | 20-29 |
| 04:24 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson can't connect on a 3 pointer from the right corner | 20-29 |
| 04:23 | Otterbein | Clarence Hutcherson grabs the defensive rebound | 20-29 |
| 04:19 | Otterbein | Andrew Weiner denies the turnaround by Henry Newbury | 20-29 |
| 04:18 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson snags the defensive board | 20-29 |
| 03:53 | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson hits the front of the rim on the wide open 3 pointer from straight away | 20-29 |
| 03:52 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Clarence Hutcherson | 20-29 |
| 03:47 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin misses the jump hook from the baseline but he's fouled by James Newcomb - foul #1 on James Newcomb, team foul #9 | 20-29 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Shelby Coppola (SG), Allan Mason (SF), Edward Green (PF), Chad Marquardt (C) Henry Newbury, Jeffrey Berkey, Clarence Hutcherson, Cody Harrison | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass (PG), Charles Barlow (SG), Frederick Cox (SF), Stephen French (PF), Galen Thompson (C) Buford Schmidt, James Newcomb, Johnnie Thompson, Andrew Weiner, Albert Shook | |
| 03:47 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin makes the 1st free throw | 21-29 |
| 03:47 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin makes the 2nd free throw | 22-29 |
| 03:45 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow loses the dribble to Edward Green in the backcourt | 22-29 |
| 03:26 | Otterbein | Edward Green clanks a jumpshot from the right wing | 22-29 |
| 03:24 | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin gets the offensive rebound | 22-29 |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Ralph Griffin (tiring) 3 pts. 1 ast. SG - Shelby Coppola (fairly fresh) 7 pts. SF - Allan Mason (fresh) PF - Edward Green (tired) 2 reb. C - Chad Marquardt (fairly fresh) 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Shenandoah | PG - Johnny Snodgrass (fresh) 1 ast. SG - Charles Barlow (tired) 3 pts. 1 ast. SF - Frederick Cox (fairly fresh) 2 pts. PF - Stephen French (fresh) C - Galen Thompson (fresh) | |
| 03:10 | Otterbein | Edward Green hits the finger roll on a great pass from Shelby Coppola and he's fouled by Stephen French - foul #1 on Stephen French, team foul #10 | 24-29 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol (PG) Ralph Griffin | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Jack Seavey (C) Galen Thompson | |
| 03:10 | Otterbein | Edward Green misses the free throw | 24-29 |
| 03:10 | Shenandoah | Jack Seavey grabs the board | 24-29 |
| 02:51 | Shenandoah | Charles Barlow drills a jumper in the paint | 24-31 |
| 02:49 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol is hacked by Charles Barlow in the backcourt - foul #2 on Charles Barlow, team foul #11 | 24-31 |
| Subs | Otterbein | James Hamberg (SF), Clarence Hutcherson (PF) Allan Mason, Edward Green | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson (SF), Eric Benito (PF) Frederick Cox, Stephen French | |
| 02:49 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol misses the 1st free throw | 24-31 |
| 02:49 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol makes the 2nd free throw | 25-31 |
| 02:46 | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass is whistled for a carry in the backcourt | 25-31 |
| 02:34 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol is fouled on the floor by Charles Barlow - foul #3 on Charles Barlow, team foul #12 | 25-31 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | James Newcomb (SG) Charles Barlow | |
| 02:34 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol makes the 1st free throw | 26-31 |
| 02:34 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol makes the 2nd free throw | 27-31 |
| 02:14 | Shenandoah | Eric Benito can't finish the layup | 27-31 |
| 02:12 | Otterbein | Chad Marquardt pulls down the rebound | 27-31 |
| 02:09 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol is fouled in the backcourt by Eric Benito - foul #2 on Eric Benito, team foul #13 | 27-31 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Jerome Pritchett (SF), Allan Mason (C) James Hamberg, Chad Marquardt | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Frederick Cox (SF), Galen Thompson (C) Johnnie Thompson, Jack Seavey | |
| 02:09 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol misses the 1st free throw | 27-31 |
| 02:09 | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol makes the 2nd free throw | 28-31 |
| 01:49 | Shenandoah | Shelby Coppola is called for the reach on James Newcomb - foul #3 on Shelby Coppola, team foul #7 | 28-31 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Griffin (PG), Edward Green (PF), Cody Harrison (C) Ralph Bristol, Shelby Coppola, Clarence Hutcherson | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Buford Schmidt (PG) Eric Benito | |
| 01:49 | Shenandoah | James Newcomb makes the 1st free throw | 28-32 |
| 01:49 | Shenandoah | James Newcomb makes the 2nd free throw | 28-33 |
| 01:39 | Otterbein | James Newcomb steps in front of the Allan Mason pass | 28-33 |
| 01:37 | Shenandoah | Jerome Pritchett is called for the reach on Johnny Snodgrass in the backcourt - foul #2 on Jerome Pritchett, team foul #8 | 28-33 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Johnnie Thompson (SF) James Newcomb | |
| 01:37 | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass misses the 1st free throw | 28-33 |
| 01:37 | Otterbein | Cody Harrison grabs the defensive rebound | 28-33 |
| 01:30 | Otterbein | Allan Mason is fouled on the floor by Frederick Cox - foul #2 on Frederick Cox, team foul #14 | 28-33 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Jack Seavey (C) Galen Thompson | |
| 01:30 | Otterbein | Allan Mason makes the 1st free throw | 29-33 |
| 01:30 | Otterbein | Allan Mason makes the 2nd free throw | 30-33 |
| 01:23 | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass is fouled in the backcourt by Jerome Pritchett - foul #3 on Jerome Pritchett, team foul #9 | 30-33 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Henry Newbury (SG), James Hamberg (SF) Jerome Pritchett, Allan Mason | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | | |
| 01:23 | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass makes the 1st free throw | 30-34 |
| 01:23 | Shenandoah | Johnny Snodgrass makes the 2nd free throw | 30-35 |
| 01:02 | Otterbein | Johnny Snodgrass steals it from Ralph Griffin | 30-35 |
| 00:59 | Shenandoah | Buford Schmidt hits the finger roll set up by Johnny Snodgrass | 30-37 |
| 00:59 | Otterbein | Otterbein calls a full timeout (2 :30 2 full remaining) | 30-37 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Ralph Bristol (PG), Jeffrey Berkey (SF), Chad Marquardt (PF), Clarence Hutcherson (C) Ralph Griffin, James Hamberg, Edward Green, Cody Harrison | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | Andrew Weiner (SG), Stephen French (PF) Johnny Snodgrass, Frederick Cox | |
| 00:41 | Otterbein | Henry Newbury lays it in on a nice dish by Jeffrey Berkey and he's hacked by Andrew Weiner - foul #2 on Andrew Weiner, team foul #15 | 32-37 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | Shenandoah | James Newcomb (PG) Buford Schmidt | |
| 00:41 | Otterbein | Henry Newbury makes the free throw | 33-37 |
| 00:39 | Shenandoah | Ralph Bristol is called for the reach on James Newcomb in the backcourt - foul #2 on Ralph Bristol, team foul #10 | 33-37 |
| 00:39 | Shenandoah | James Newcomb makes the 1st free throw | 33-38 |
| 00:39 | Shenandoah | James Newcomb makes the 2nd free throw | 33-39 |
| 00:26 | Otterbein | Henry Newbury clanks a jumpshot from just outside the lane | 33-39 |
| 00:25 | Shenandoah | Andrew Weiner grabs the board | 33-39 |
| 00:22 | Shenandoah | Ralph Bristol steals the ball from James Newcomb in the backcourt | 33-39 |
| 00:01 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Berkey misses long on a shot near the basket | 33-39 |
| 00:00 | Otterbein | The clock runs out | 33-39 |