| Lineup | Carthage | PG - Kevin Fenley (fresh) SG - Christopher Lieu (fresh) SF - Jon Sawyer (fresh) PF - John Price (fresh) C - William Wilson (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Michael Olson (fresh) SG - Robert Layman (fresh) SF - Jerry Shelton (fresh) PF - Robert Hanna (fresh) C - Garrett Epperson (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | Otterbein | Garrett Epperson wins the tip | 0-0 |
| Game Plan | Carthage | Carthage is playing a motion offense and a 2-3 zone (0) | |
| Game Plan | Otterbein | Otterbein is playing a fastbreak offense and a fullcourt press (0) | |
| 19:43 | Otterbein | Garrett Epperson can't connect on a shot in the paint | 0-0 |
| 19:41 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley gets the rebound | 0-0 |
| 19:38 | Carthage | Jon Sawyer double dribbles in the backcourt | 0-0 |
| 19:27 | Otterbein | Robert Hanna's fadeaway is rejected by William Wilson | 0-0 |
| 19:25 | Carthage | William Wilson snags the defensive board | 0-0 |
| 19:08 | Carthage | Jon Sawyer knocks in the 3pt shot from the right corner | 3-0 |
| 18:49 | Otterbein | Michael Olson misses badly on a 3pt jumper from straight away | 3-0 |
| 18:48 | Carthage | William Wilson snags the defensive board | 3-0 |
| 18:46 | Carthage | Michael Olson picks off the pass by Jon Sawyer in the backcourt | 3-0 |
| 18:44 | Otterbein | Michael Olson lays it in | 3-2 |
| 18:20 | Carthage | William Wilson misses badly on the uncontested driving attempt from the left block | 3-2 |
| 18:18 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley snags the offensive board | 3-2 |
| 18:01 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley comes up short on the 3pt jumper from the left corner | 3-2 |
| 18:00 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Robert Hanna | 3-2 |
| 17:47 | Otterbein | Robert Hanna hits the front of the rim on the floater from the left side | 3-2 |
| 17:46 | Otterbein | Robert Hanna tips it in | 3-4 |
| 17:36 | Carthage | William Wilson blows the layup but the foul's on Garrett Epperson - foul #1 on Garrett Epperson, team foul #1 | 3-4 |
| Subs | Carthage | James Couture (PG), Chris Muro (SG), Christopher Hinnant (SF), Frank Zerbe (PF) Kevin Fenley, Christopher Lieu, Jon Sawyer, John Price | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Clinton Magee (PG), Robert Schmidt (SG), Paul Woods (SF), Christopher McCutcheon (PF), Thomas Shuck (C) Michael Olson, Robert Layman, Jerry Shelton, Robert Hanna, Garrett Epperson | |
| 17:36 | Carthage | William Wilson makes the 1st free throw | 4-4 |
| 17:36 | Carthage | William Wilson makes the 2nd free throw | 5-4 |
| 17:25 | Otterbein | Robert Schmidt clanks a 3pt attempt from the right corner | 5-4 |
| 17:23 | Otterbein | The offensive rebound goes to Christopher McCutcheon | 5-4 |
| 17:18 | Otterbein | Christopher McCutcheon makes the shot near the basket | 5-6 |
| 17:04 | Carthage | James Couture misses short on an open 3pt attempt from straight away | 5-6 |
| 17:03 | Carthage | William Wilson tips it in | 7-6 |
| 16:43 | Otterbein | Thomas Shuck loses the dribble to James Couture | 7-6 |
| 16:39 | Carthage | Christopher Hinnant lays it in set up by James Couture | 9-6 |
| 16:14 | Otterbein | Frank Zerbe is called for the reach on Christopher McCutcheon - foul #1 on Frank Zerbe, team foul #1 | 9-6 |
| Subs | Carthage | Kevin Fenley (PG), Christopher Lieu (SG), Jeremy Romeo (SF), Richard Carbaugh (C) James Couture, Chris Muro, Christopher Hinnant, William Wilson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Robert Layman (SG), Jerry Shelton (SF), Robert Hanna (PF) Robert Schmidt, Christopher McCutcheon, Thomas Shuck | |
| 15:59 | Otterbein | Jerry Shelton banks in the layup | 9-8 |
| Lineup | Carthage | PG - Kevin Fenley (fresh) SG - Christopher Lieu (fresh) SF - Jeremy Romeo (fresh) PF - Frank Zerbe (fresh) C - Richard Carbaugh (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Clinton Magee (fresh) SG - Robert Layman (fairly fresh) SF - Jerry Shelton (fairly fresh) 2 pts. PF - Robert Hanna (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. C - Paul Woods (fresh) | |
| 15:43 | Carthage | Frank Zerbe knocks in the 3 pointer from the right wing set up by Richard Carbaugh | 12-8 |
| 15:38 | Otterbein | Robert Layman misses short on a 3 from straight away | 12-8 |
| 15:37 | Carthage | Richard Carbaugh grabs the defensive rebound | 12-8 |
| 15:34 | Carthage | Jerry Shelton is called for the reach on Jeremy Romeo in the backcourt - foul #1 on Jerry Shelton, team foul #2 | 12-8 |
| Subs | Carthage | Jon Sawyer (SF), John Price (PF) Jeremy Romeo, Frank Zerbe | |
| Subs | Otterbein | John Tapia (PG), Garrett Epperson (C) Clinton Magee, Paul Woods | |
| 15:16 | Carthage | John Price can't connect on a fadeaway jumper from the left side | 12-8 |
| 15:14 | Carthage | John Price grabs the offensive board | 12-8 |
| 14:58 | Carthage | John Tapia is called for the reach on Jon Sawyer - foul #1 on John Tapia, team foul #3 | 12-8 |
| Subs | Carthage | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Olson (PG), Robert Schmidt (SG), Thomas Shuck (C) John Tapia, Robert Layman, Garrett Epperson | |
| 14:41 | Carthage | Jon Sawyer's layup is rejected by Thomas Shuck | 12-8 |
| 14:40 | Otterbein | Thomas Shuck pulls down the rebound | 12-8 |
| 14:33 | Otterbein | Richard Carbaugh is called for the reach on Thomas Shuck - foul #1 on Richard Carbaugh, team foul #2 | 12-8 |
| Subs | Carthage | James Couture (SG), Frank Zerbe (C) Christopher Lieu, Richard Carbaugh | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Christopher McCutcheon (SF) Jerry Shelton | |
| 14:21 | Otterbein | Christopher McCutcheon's dunk attempt is rejected by John Price | 12-8 |
| 14:19 | Otterbein | Robert Hanna tips it home | 12-10 |
| 14:05 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley comes up short on the 3pt shot from straight away | 12-10 |
| 14:04 | Otterbein | Christopher McCutcheon gets the rebound | 12-10 |
| 13:49 | Otterbein | Christopher McCutcheon throws a bad pass out of bounds | 12-10 |
| Subs | Carthage | Chris Muro (SG), Christopher Hinnant (SF), Jeremy Romeo (PF) Kevin Fenley, Jon Sawyer, John Price | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Clinton Magee (PG), Robert Layman (SG), Paul Woods (SF), Garrett Epperson (C) Michael Olson, Robert Schmidt, Robert Hanna, Thomas Shuck | |
| 13:38 | Carthage | Jeremy Romeo misses badly on the uncontested shot from the baseline | 12-10 |
| 13:36 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Garrett Epperson | 12-10 |
| 13:32 | Otterbein | Paul Woods can't connect on a 3pt shot from straight away | 12-10 |
| 13:31 | Carthage | Jeremy Romeo grabs the board | 12-10 |
| 13:11 | Carthage | Christopher Hinnant's floater is tipped away by Garrett Epperson | 12-10 |
| 13:10 | Otterbein | Robert Layman grabs the board | 12-10 |
| 12:56 | Otterbein | Robert Layman comes up short on the 3pt jumper from the left corner | 12-10 |
| 12:55 | Otterbein | Garrett Epperson grabs the offensive board | 12-10 |
| 12:37 | Otterbein | Clinton Magee is hacked by Frank Zerbe - foul #2 on Frank Zerbe, team foul #3 | 12-10 |
| Subs | Carthage | Kevin Fenley (PG), Christopher Lieu (SG), Richard Carbaugh (C) James Couture, Chris Muro, Frank Zerbe | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Olson (PG), Jerry Shelton (SF), Robert Hanna (PF) Robert Layman, Christopher McCutcheon, Garrett Epperson | |
| 12:19 | Otterbein | Michael Olson misses short on a jumper from the right wing | 12-10 |
| 12:17 | Carthage | Jeremy Romeo gets the rebound | 12-10 |
| 11:51 | Carthage | Richard Carbaugh comes up short on the turnaround in the paint | 12-10 |
| 11:50 | Otterbein | Clinton Magee gets the rebound | 12-10 |
| Lineup | Carthage | PG - Kevin Fenley (fresh) SG - Christopher Lieu (fresh) SF - Christopher Hinnant (fairly fresh) 2 pts. PF - Jeremy Romeo (fairly fresh) 2 reb. C - Richard Carbaugh (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Michael Olson (fresh) 2 pts. SG - Clinton Magee (fairly fresh) SF - Jerry Shelton (fairly fresh) 2 pts. PF - Robert Hanna (fairly fresh) 4 pts. 3 reb. C - Paul Woods (fairly fresh) | |
| 11:42 | Otterbein | Clinton Magee hits the front of the rim on the 3pt shot from straight away | 12-10 |
| 11:40 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley gets the rebound | 12-10 |
| 11:23 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley drills a 3pt shot from the left wing set up by Christopher Lieu | 15-10 |
| 11:19 | Otterbein | Clinton Magee hits the front of the rim on the 3 from the right corner | 15-10 |
| 11:18 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley pulls down the rebound | 15-10 |
| 11:15 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu is hacked by Clinton Magee in the backcourt - foul #1 on Clinton Magee, team foul #4 | 15-10 |
| Subs | Carthage | James Couture (PG), Jon Sawyer (SF), John Price (PF), William Wilson (C) Kevin Fenley, Christopher Hinnant, Jeremy Romeo, Richard Carbaugh | |
| Subs | Otterbein | John Tapia (PG), Robert Schmidt (SG), Thomas Shuck (C) Michael Olson, Clinton Magee, Paul Woods | |
| 10:58 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu drills a fadeaway jumper from just outside the lane on a great pass from James Couture | 17-10 |
| 10:40 | Otterbein | Robert Schmidt knocks in the 3pt jumper from the right corner set up by Jerry Shelton | 17-13 |
| 10:18 | Carthage | Jon Sawyer double dribbles | 17-13 |
| Subs | Carthage | Kevin Fenley (PG) Christopher Lieu | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Christopher McCutcheon (SF) Jerry Shelton | |
| 10:06 | Otterbein | Thomas Shuck knocks in the 3pt jumper from straight away | 17-16 |
| 10:04 | Carthage | Christopher McCutcheon steps in front of the Jon Sawyer pass in the backcourt | 17-16 |
| 10:02 | Otterbein | Christopher McCutcheon banks in the layup | 17-18 |
| 09:59 | Carthage | John Price is whistled for a carry in the backcourt | 17-18 |
| Subs | Carthage | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Robert Layman (SG) John Tapia | |
| 09:52 | Otterbein | Robert Layman scores on a 3 from the left wing set up by Robert Hanna | 17-21 |
| 09:41 | Carthage | James Couture comes up short on the 3 from straight away | 17-21 |
| 09:40 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Thomas Shuck | 17-21 |
| 09:35 | Otterbein | Robert Schmidt connects on the 3pt jumper from the right wing on a nice dish by Robert Hanna | 17-24 |
| 09:23 | Carthage | John Price misses short on a 3 from the right wing | 17-24 |
| 09:21 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Thomas Shuck | 17-24 |
| 09:19 | Otterbein | Robert Schmidt's pass is off the mark and out of bounds in the backcourt | 17-24 |
| Subs | Carthage | Chris Muro (SG), Roger Stalter (PF), Richard Carbaugh (C) James Couture, John Price, William Wilson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Olson (PG), Paul Woods (SF), Garrett Epperson (C) Robert Schmidt, Robert Hanna, Thomas Shuck | |
| 09:05 | Carthage | Roger Stalter can't connect on a turnaround in the lane but the foul's on Christopher McCutcheon - foul #1 on Christopher McCutcheon, team foul #5 | 17-24 |
| Subs | Carthage | Christopher Lieu (SG) Kevin Fenley | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 09:05 | Carthage | Roger Stalter makes the 1st free throw | 18-24 |
| 09:05 | Carthage | Roger Stalter misses the 2nd free throw | 18-24 |
| 09:05 | Carthage | Richard Carbaugh snags the offensive board | 18-24 |
| 08:52 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu is by himself and knocks in the jumper from the free throw line | 20-24 |
| 08:46 | Otterbein | Paul Woods misses short on a jumper from the baseline but he's hacked by Jon Sawyer - foul #1 on Jon Sawyer, team foul #4 | 20-24 |
| Subs | Carthage | Christopher Hinnant (SF) Jon Sawyer | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Clinton Magee (SG), Robert Hanna (PF) Robert Layman, Christopher McCutcheon | |
| 08:46 | Otterbein | Paul Woods makes the 1st free throw | 20-25 |
| 08:46 | Otterbein | Paul Woods makes the 2nd free throw | 20-26 |
| 08:20 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu is hacked by Clinton Magee - foul #2 on Clinton Magee, team foul #6 | 20-26 |
| Subs | Carthage | Jeremy Romeo (PF) Roger Stalter | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Robert Layman (SG) Clinton Magee | |
| 08:09 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu misses long on a jumpshot from the right wing but the foul's on Robert Layman - foul #1 on Robert Layman, team foul #7 | 20-26 |
| Subs | Carthage | James Couture (PG) Chris Muro | |
| Subs | Otterbein | John Tapia (PG), Jerry Shelton (SF) Michael Olson, Paul Woods | |
| 08:09 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu makes the 1st free throw | 21-26 |
| 08:09 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu makes the 2nd free throw | 22-26 |
| 07:49 | Otterbein | Robert Layman drills a jumper from just outside the lane | 22-28 |
| Lineup | Carthage | PG - James Couture (fresh) 2 ast. SG - Christopher Lieu (fairly fresh) 6 pts. 1 ast. SF - Christopher Hinnant (fresh) 2 pts. PF - Jeremy Romeo (fresh) 2 reb. C - Richard Carbaugh (fresh) 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - John Tapia (fresh) SG - Robert Layman (fairly fresh) 5 pts. SF - Jerry Shelton (fairly fresh) 2 pts. PF - Robert Hanna (tiring) 4 pts. 3 reb. C - Garrett Epperson (fairly fresh) 2 reb. | |
| 07:44 | Carthage | Jeremy Romeo is called for the illegal screen - foul #1 on Jeremy Romeo, team foul #5 | 22-28 |
| Subs | Carthage | Kevin Fenley (PG), John Price (PF), William Wilson (C) Christopher Lieu, Christopher Hinnant, Richard Carbaugh | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Christopher McCutcheon (PF) Robert Hanna | |
| 07:30 | Otterbein | Robert Layman throws a bad pass out of bounds | 22-28 |
| Subs | Carthage | Roger Stalter (SF) Jeremy Romeo | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Robert Schmidt (SG), Thomas Shuck (C) Robert Layman, Garrett Epperson | |
| 07:21 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley hits a 3pt jumper from straight away on a nice dish by Roger Stalter | 25-28 |
| 07:06 | Otterbein | Jerry Shelton hits the front of the rim on the jumper near the basket but he's hacked by Roger Stalter - foul #1 on Roger Stalter, team foul #6 | 25-28 |
| Subs | Carthage | Chris Muro (SG) James Couture | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Olson (PG), Paul Woods (C) John Tapia, Christopher McCutcheon | |
| 07:06 | Otterbein | Jerry Shelton makes the 1st free throw | 25-29 |
| 07:06 | Otterbein | Jerry Shelton makes the 2nd free throw | 25-30 |
| 06:53 | Carthage | Chris Muro clanks a 3pt shot from the right corner | 25-30 |
| 06:52 | Otterbein | Paul Woods grabs the board | 25-30 |
| 06:32 | Otterbein | Kevin Fenley steps in front of the Paul Woods pass | 25-30 |
| 06:28 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley lays it up and in | 27-30 |
| 06:22 | Otterbein | Paul Woods throws a bad pass out of bounds | 27-30 |
| Subs | Carthage | Christopher Lieu (SG), Jon Sawyer (SF), Richard Carbaugh (C) Chris Muro, Roger Stalter, William Wilson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Robert Layman (SG), Robert Hanna (PF), Garrett Epperson (C) Robert Schmidt, Jerry Shelton, Thomas Shuck | |
| 06:20 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu is fouled in the backcourt by Michael Olson - foul #1 on Michael Olson, team foul #8 | 27-30 |
| Subs | Carthage | Christopher Hinnant (PG) Kevin Fenley | |
| Subs | Otterbein | John Tapia (PG) Michael Olson | |
| 06:20 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu misses the 1st free throw | 27-30 |
| 06:20 | Otterbein | Garrett Epperson pulls down the rebound | 27-30 |
| 06:18 | Otterbein | John Tapia's pass is intercepted by Christopher Hinnant in the backcourt | 27-30 |
| 06:01 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu connects on the driving attempt near the basket | 29-30 |
| 05:40 | Otterbein | Garrett Epperson can't connect on a jumpshot from the right side but he's hacked by Christopher Lieu - foul #1 on Christopher Lieu, team foul #7 | 29-30 |
| Subs | Carthage | James Couture (PG), Jeremy Romeo (PF) Christopher Hinnant, John Price | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Olson (PG), Jerry Shelton (SF) John Tapia, Paul Woods | |
| 05:40 | Otterbein | Garrett Epperson misses the 1st free throw | 29-30 |
| 05:40 | Otterbein | Garrett Epperson makes the 2nd free throw | 29-31 |
| 05:25 | Carthage | Jeremy Romeo makes the fadeaway in the lane | 31-31 |
| 04:58 | Otterbein | Robert Hanna misses long on a runner near the basket | 31-31 |
| 04:56 | Carthage | James Couture gets the rebound | 31-31 |
| 04:34 | Carthage | Jerry Shelton steals the ball from Christopher Lieu | 31-31 |
| 04:26 | Otterbein | Michael Olson misses the jumpshot from the right wing | 31-31 |
| 04:25 | Otterbein | Robert Layman tips it home | 31-33 |
| 04:10 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu knocks in the floater near the basket on a nice dish by James Couture and he's hacked by Robert Layman - foul #2 on Robert Layman, team foul #9 | 33-33 |
| Subs | Carthage | Kevin Fenley (PG), Christopher Hinnant (SF), Roger Stalter (PF), William Wilson (C) James Couture, Jon Sawyer, Jeremy Romeo, Richard Carbaugh | |
| Subs | Otterbein | John Tapia (PG), Robert Schmidt (SG), Paul Woods (SF), Christopher McCutcheon (PF), Thomas Shuck (C) Michael Olson, Robert Layman, Jerry Shelton, Robert Hanna, Garrett Epperson | |
| 04:10 | Carthage | Christopher Lieu misses the free throw | 33-33 |
| 04:10 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Christopher McCutcheon | 33-33 |
| 03:53 | Otterbein | Robert Schmidt misses long on a 3 pointer from straight away | 33-33 |
| 03:51 | Carthage | William Wilson grabs the defensive rebound | 33-33 |
| Lineup | Carthage | PG - Kevin Fenley (fresh) 8 pts. SG - Christopher Lieu (fairly fresh) 10 pts. 1 ast. SF - Christopher Hinnant (fresh) 2 pts. PF - Roger Stalter (fresh) 1 pts. C - William Wilson (fresh) 4 pts. 4 reb. | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - John Tapia (fresh) SG - Robert Schmidt (fresh) 6 pts. SF - Paul Woods (fresh) 2 pts. PF - Christopher McCutcheon (fresh) 4 pts. 3 reb. C - Thomas Shuck (fresh) 3 pts. 3 reb. | |
| 03:28 | Carthage | Roger Stalter's layup is rejected by Paul Woods | 33-33 |
| 03:27 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley tips it but misses | 33-33 |
| 03:26 | Otterbein | Thomas Shuck pulls down the rebound | 33-33 |
| 03:09 | Otterbein | John Tapia hits the front of the rim on the floater from the free throw line | 33-33 |
| 03:08 | Carthage | Christopher Hinnant snags the defensive board | 33-33 |
| 02:47 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley throws a bad pass out of bounds | 33-33 |
| Subs | Carthage | James Couture (SG), Jon Sawyer (SF), John Price (PF), Frank Zerbe (C) Christopher Lieu, Christopher Hinnant, Roger Stalter, William Wilson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Clinton Magee (PG), Robert Layman (SG), Jerry Shelton (SF) John Tapia, Robert Schmidt, Paul Woods | |
| 02:21 | Otterbein | Thomas Shuck misses long on a driving attempt in the lane but the foul's on James Couture - foul #1 on James Couture, team foul #8 | 33-33 |
| Subs | Carthage | Chris Muro (SG) Kevin Fenley | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Robert Hanna (PF) Christopher McCutcheon | |
| 02:21 | Otterbein | Thomas Shuck makes the 1st free throw | 33-34 |
| 02:21 | Otterbein | Thomas Shuck makes the 2nd free throw | 33-35 |
| 02:16 | Carthage | Clinton Magee steps in front of the Jon Sawyer pass in the backcourt | 33-35 |
| 02:08 | Otterbein | Clinton Magee knocks in the 3pt jumper from straight away | 33-38 |
| 02:06 | Carthage | James Couture is fouled in the backcourt by Clinton Magee - foul #3 on Clinton Magee, team foul #10 | 33-38 |
| Subs | Carthage | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Olson (PG), Garrett Epperson (C) Clinton Magee, Thomas Shuck | |
| 02:06 | Carthage | James Couture makes the 1st free throw | 34-38 |
| 02:06 | Carthage | James Couture makes the 2nd free throw | 35-38 |
| 01:47 | Otterbein | Jerry Shelton's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 35-38 |
| Subs | Carthage | Jeremy Romeo (SF) Jon Sawyer | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 01:35 | Carthage | Chris Muro is open but comes up short on the 3pt shot from the left corner | 35-38 |
| 01:34 | Carthage | James Couture tips it back up and in | 37-38 |
| 01:12 | Otterbein | Michael Olson throws a bad pass out of bounds | 37-38 |
| Subs | Carthage | Kevin Fenley (PG), Christopher Hinnant (SF) James Couture, John Price | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Robert Schmidt (SG), Paul Woods (SF), Christopher McCutcheon (PF), Thomas Shuck (C) Robert Layman, Jerry Shelton, Robert Hanna, Garrett Epperson | |
| 01:10 | Carthage | Chris Muro's pass is off the mark and out of bounds in the backcourt | 37-38 |
| Subs | Carthage | Richard Carbaugh (C) Jeremy Romeo | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 01:01 | Otterbein | Michael Olson is fouled on the floor by Christopher Hinnant - foul #1 on Christopher Hinnant, team foul #9 | 37-38 |
| Subs | Carthage | John Price (PF) Frank Zerbe | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 01:01 | Otterbein | Michael Olson makes the 1st free throw | 37-39 |
| 01:01 | Otterbein | Michael Olson makes the 2nd free throw | 37-40 |
| 00:41 | Carthage | Richard Carbaugh is open and scores on a shot from just outside the lane | 39-40 |
| 00:19 | Otterbein | Michael Olson is fouled on the floor by Kevin Fenley - foul #1 on Kevin Fenley, team foul #10 | 39-40 |
| Subs | Carthage | Christopher Lieu (SG), Jon Sawyer (SF), William Wilson (C) Chris Muro, Christopher Hinnant, Richard Carbaugh | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Robert Hanna (PF) Thomas Shuck | |
| 00:19 | Otterbein | Michael Olson makes the 1st free throw | 39-41 |
| 00:19 | Otterbein | Michael Olson makes the 2nd free throw | 39-42 |
| 00:00 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley is fouled on the floor by Michael Olson - foul #2 on Michael Olson, team foul #11 | 39-42 |
| Subs | Carthage | Jeremy Romeo (SF), Frank Zerbe (PF) Jon Sawyer, John Price | |
| Subs | Otterbein | John Tapia (PG), Robert Layman (SG), Garrett Epperson (C) Michael Olson, Robert Schmidt, Christopher McCutcheon | |
| 00:00 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley makes the 1st free throw | 40-42 |
| 00:00 | Carthage | Kevin Fenley makes the 2nd free throw | 41-42 |